Friday, 10 July 2015 05:57

It’s this year’s cashflow that counts

Written by 
Hayden Dillon, Crowe Howarth. Hayden Dillon, Crowe Howarth.

There are good lessons to be drawn from the global financial crisis (GFC) for dairy farmers in managing volatility and getting the most from their banking relationship, says Hayden Dillon, head of corporate agribusiness and capital advisory for Crowe Horwath.

Major rural banks were expected to support their dairy clients despite many farm budgets indicating negative cashflow positions for the coming year, he said. And post-GFC, banks had undergone significant reforms and were now well positioned for access to capital. 

“It’s critical to note that major rural lenders do not assess the viability of farms based on last year’s or next year’s payout,” says Dillon. “Banks are acutely aware of the market they operate in, which will sometimes see their customers run cash deficits due to volatility.”

Because of that, the banks used averaging, known generically as a ‘sustainable year,’ to assess a farmer’s ability to service and repay debt. 

With that in mind, farmers should pay attention to three key themes to get the most from their banking relationship, says Dillon. These are:   

Understanding what their normalised costs are, and being able to justify those costs to their banker.

Having accurate information on hand and a process to make decisions quickly and effectively when faced with major events, such as drought, flood, change in milk price, or in the cost of inputs.

Understanding the potential ramifications of their banker making assumptions on the farmer’s behalf, as opposed to providing assistance and advice.

In good payout years farm costs invariably increased, but when things got tough, farmers were also good at tightening their belts, said Dillon.

“Unfortunately for those with leverage it’s not good enough to just say you will cut costs when talking to your bank.”

While banks would draw considerable comfort from being shown that historical expenditure during good periods had led to ongoing increases in productivity, they also wanted to see that in the event of a low payout, those expenditures could be reduced without materially impacting production. 

The objective is to provide a set of normalised accounts to allow a ‘sustainable year’ evaluation to be done. This needs to be completed by an independent adviser so the farmer had credibility with the ultimate decision-maker at the bank, said Dillon. 

“The ultimate decision maker at the bank is most likely not your banker, especially when the business falls outside the terms upon which any funding was initially agreed.”

Dillon said that during the GFC there were consequences of farmers relying on their banker to do their budget.  “In some cases this led to considerable stress, because the bank and the farmer had different expectations. And when things changed, the bank struggled to establish the communication necessary to enable both parties to manage their way through.” 

In regards to budgeting, Dillon stressed the importance of constantly reviewing things as situations change, “Volatility of commodities, seasonal variations and input costs mean cashflow budgeting cannot be a ‘set and forget’ for the season.”

It’s also important to be prepared for any eventuality. 

“Having budgeting discussions and considering possible scenarios now will help ensure you are in a position to be aware of the information you will require and the people you will need around you, says Dillon. 

More like this

Farmer resilience will be tested

OPINION: Perhaps Captain Bligh’s infamous line, “the beatings will continue until morale improves”, best summed up the mood of New Zealand’s weary agribusiness sector at Fieldays last year.

Hedging decisions risky

With an 80% likelihood the Reserve Bank will lower the official cash rate by 25 basis points next month, many rural borrowers are wondering if now is the time to look at fixing rates.

Vigilance around fixed rate mortgages

Market commentators are indicating with 80% certainty the Reserve Bank of New Zealand will lower the official cash rate by 25 basis points next month and then it will begin to stabilise.

Featured

Vaccinate against new lepto strain

A vet is calling for all animals to be vaccinated against a new strain of leptospirosis (lepto) discovered on New Zealand dairy farms in recent years.

Funding boost for red meat

Two major red meat sector projects are getting up to a combined $1.7 million in funding from the New Zealand Meat Board (NZMB).

Otago's supreme winner

Angus Barr and Tara Dwyer of The Wandle, Lone Star Farms in Strath Taieri have been named the Regional Supreme Winners at the Otago Ballance Farm Environment Awards in Dunedin.

Editorial: Wake up Wellington

OPINION: The distress that the politicians and bureaucrats are causing to the people of Wairoa and the wider Tairāwhiti is unforgivable.

TV series to combat food waste

Rural banker Rabobank is partnering with Food Rescue Kitchen on a new TV series which airs this weekend that aims to shine a light on the real and growing issues of food waste, food poverty and social isolation in New Zealand.

National

Frontline biosecurity 'untouchable'

Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard has reiterated that 'frontline' biosecurity services within Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) will not be cut…

Machinery & Products

New name, new ideas

KGM New Zealand, is part of the London headquartered Inchcape Group, who increased its NZ presence in August 2023 with…

All-terrain fert spreading mode

Effluent specialists the Samson Group have developed a new double unloading system to help optimise uphill and downhill organic fertiliser…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Plant-based bubble bursts

OPINION: Talking about plant-based food: “Chicken-free chicken” start-up Sunfed has had its valuation slashed to zero by major investor Blackbird…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter