fbpx
Print this page
Tuesday, 24 August 2021 06:55

Over regulated

Written by  Peter Burke
Former High Commissioner Sir Lockwood Smith. Former High Commissioner Sir Lockwood Smith.

New Zealand is adopting a top-heavy regulatory approach similar to the European Union, according to former High Commissioner and Trade Minister Sir Lockwood Smith.

He told Rural News that EU regulations are top-down heavy, expensive and don't work. He says the present government is following a similar philosophy to the EU with its regulatory approach.

"That is one of the reasons why the UK left the EU. They wanted to get into world's best practice for regulations and NZ, Australia and America were seen to be leading the way in this, with the focus on outcomes and a light-handed approach that produces good outcomes that are basically risk-managed."

Smith says at the recent Red Meat Sector Conference there were claims that farmers did not understand the environmental issues and there was criticism of the Groundswell protests.

He says the reality is that most farmers want to improve the quality of freshwater, improve biodiversity and make progress on carbon emissions.

"The problem is the way the Government is going about it. Theirs is an intractable, unworkable, heavy-handed, top-down way," he says.

"The freshwater regulations are a disaster because NZ catchments and soil types and its environment changes so much across the country and one set of regulations will never work. They are just killing off some of the excellent fresh water work going on around our regions."

Smith also rejected claims by a speaker at the conference who claimed that NZ agriculture was not innovating enough. He says the agriculture sector has made huge gains over the years through quality, science-based research and is continuing to do this.

"The only period when NZ agriculture didn't innovate was the period from 1973 through to 1984 when we had the big subsidies. Subsidies kill innovation but agriculture has been hugely innovative since then," he says.

Finally, Smith - who before entering Parliament spent 13 years in universities, including lecturing at Massey University and as Commonwealth Scholar at the Waite Research Institute in Adelaide - says he's concerned that NZ's universities are becoming a little "side tracked".

He says NZ needs to be doing work on things like regenerative agriculture, but making sure that if we go down that track, it is backed by sound science.

"If it is just a marketing thing, one day the bubble will burst," Smith told Rural News. "If you have not based your productive system on sound science it will collapse and NZ cannot afford that."

He says we have to ensure, as we have up until now, that sound science underpins our productive systems.

More like this

EU/NZ FTA signed soon?

The European Union's ambassador to NZ, Nina Obermaier, is hopeful that the FTA negotiated last year will be signed off by the middle of this year.

Sweet deal for EU honey exports

The impact of a new European Union free trade agreement removing a 17.3% tariff on NZ-sourced honey in July is translating into increasing sales volumes, according to one exporter.

Leading change in Irish dairying

A recent trip to the Green Isle as a guest of Enterprise Ireland allowed Dairy News to take a closer look at Irish agriculture and a look at one of its leading educational and research centres.

Editorial: Face the facts!

OPINION: Since the announcement of the trade agreement between NZ and the EU there has been considerable outcry.

Our best offer - EU claims

The European Union's ambassador to NZ says it has gone the extra mile to open up its market by signing a free trade agreement with NZ.

Featured

Feds make case for rural bank lending probe

Bankers have been making record profits in the last few years, but those aren’t the only records they’ve been breaking, says Federated Farmers vice president Richard McIntyre.

National

Fonterra unveils divestment plan

Fonterra is exploring full or partial divestment options for its global Consumer business, as well as its integrated businesses Fonterra…

Fonterra appoints new CFO

Fonterra has appointed a new chief financial officer, seven months after its last CFO’s shock resignation.

Machinery & Products

GPS in control

In a move that will make harvesting operations easier, particularly in odd-shaped paddocks, Kuhn has announced that GPS section control…