Synlait CEO Resignation Highlights Deeper Challenges Facing Dairy Processor
A revolving door of chief executives at milk processor Synlait is a warning sign, says Lincon University senior lecturer in agribusiness Nic Lees.
Canterbury milk processor Synlait Milk will get a new chairman next month.
Simon Robertson takes over from one of the company founders, John Penno, who stepped into the role last year as part of a plan to steer the listed processor back to profitability.
Robertson, who joined Synlait's board in 2020, is a professional company director. His new role will be ratified at Synlait's annual general meeting on December 2.
Synlait's AGM notice says Robertson has extensive commercial experience including 10 years with Auckland International Airport (AIAL), during a period of significant investment and strategic growth.
As the chief financial officer for AIAL he led the finance, accounting, business technology and procurement functions along with investor relations and regulatory affairs.
Synlait says Robertson has a proven track-record in strategyand capital-intensive infrastructure investment.
He is a director of Ballance Agri Nutrients, ITM, Apata Group, and previously served on the boards of Flick Energy and North Queensland Airports. He also chairs Synlait's audit & risk committee.
At Synlait's 2021 annual meeting, shareholders agreed to change the constitution to enable Penno, a board-appointed director, to become chair on a temporary basis.
The company says this was a temporary measure to guide Synlait’s new chief executive Grant Watson through his induction and establishment.
Penno also held the role of interim chief executive prior to Watson’s appointment.
Synlait reported a $28.5 million loss for FY2021, its first loss after nine years of profitability.
Penno then took charge and announced a plan to return to “robust profitability”.
Synlait’s woes began in December 2020 when a2 Milk suddenly reduced its demand for infant formula.
It typically produces 45% to 50% of its infant base powder during the shoulder. Inventories are held to produce fully finished consumer-packaged infant formula volumes as customer demand formalises in future months.
In the shoulder season of FY20, Synlait produced infant base powder inventories on a forward demand forecast that assumed ongoing growth of infant nutrition demand into FY21.
The company entered FY21 with large volumes of nutritionals powders on hand – 40% of forward demand with the expectation that demand would grow.
However, a2 Milk suddenly reduced demand resulting in an eventual 35% decline of nutritionals sales volumes, and a 67% decline in nutritionals powders production.
While a2 Milk’s infant formula downturn caused Synlait to underperform, a review revealed other inefficiencies within the business.
Meanwhile long-serving Synlait director Sam Knowles is retiring from the board next month. He joined the board in 2013.
Synlait says during Knowles’ tenure, the company has grown considerably.
“Sam joined Synlait just before its IPO and has made an invaluable contribution to its strategic direction and growth.
“Sam has also been chair of the people, environment and governance committee since 2019,” it says.
He will be replaced by former Fonterra executive Paul Washer.
Washer is currently chief financial officer for ASX-listed Pact Group.
Before this, he spent 17 years with Fonterra including a seven-month stint as acting chief financial officer.
New Zealand dairy farmers are set to be the first in the world to receive access to a new digital physical milk pricing tool that enables them to fix the price for their physical milk.
State farmer Pāmu is opening its farm gates this summer in an effort to give the rural sector the opportunity to see how large-scale, multi-system farming is delivering productivity and profitability across New Zealand.
A five-year study has found that the cost of reducing emissions without technology may be significant and unsustainable for Northland dairy farmers.
DairyNZ says Waikato farmers need certainty on Plan Change 1, but they say that certainty must be matched with practical, workable rules and a clear transition that doesn't get ahead of the new resource management system currently under review.
While the Government has moved quickly to make commercial hauliers' lot easier during the current fuel crisis, they appear to be stuck in the creep box when it comes to the agricultural industry.
Waikato farmers have been told that the Government’s new planning system legislation and the region’s Plan Change 1 (PC1) “won’t mesh together very well”.