fbpx
Print this page
Monday, 31 October 2022 15:55

'Forestry hysteria' not helpful - forest owners

Written by  Staff Reporters
The New Zealand Farm Forestry Association says recent comments from Beef + Lamb NZ and Federated Farmers are adding to alarm and hysteria around the issue of forestry offsets. The New Zealand Farm Forestry Association says recent comments from Beef + Lamb NZ and Federated Farmers are adding to alarm and hysteria around the issue of forestry offsets.

The New Zealand Farm Forestry Association says that recent comments from Beef + Lamb NZ (B + LNZ) and Federated Farmers are adding to alarm and hysteria around forestry.

The comments come in the aftermath of a Curia poll which found 54% of Kiwis supported a limit on the amount of fossil fuel emissions that can be offset with new pine forests.

“Picking selective facts from surveys they commissioned is building a narrative that suits their political purposes and deflects from the real issues,” says Graham West, president of the New Zealand Farm Forestry Association.

West says that asking whether people support a limit to forestry offsets or whether there is concern around the conversion of farms to forests to meet climate change, only address part of the issue.

“Both avoid the obvious question, ‘What alternatives do you prefer?’,” he says, adding that a more relevant question might be something along the lines of ‘What global temperature increase is acceptable before we start using land use change as a method of cooling the planet?’

West also points out that B + LNZ’s statistics on the number of hectares of farmland sold for forestry in 2021 are flawed.

“They ignore that 2,292 was to Manuka interests, and only 19,717 was for carbon forestry.”

He says that B + LNZ fails to give the numbers context.

“The total of whole farms sold to forestry interests that year was less than 0.5% of the area in pastoral farming,” West says.

“Farming’s leadership should be addressing the lack of progress in reducing global warming instead of deflecting public awareness on to the issue of a relatively small area being sold to forestry interests.

“Current flooding, droughts, and windstorms indicate climate change will destroy rural economies at significant scale unless tree crops are used to provide financial and environmental buffering. We need a better-informed debate than this,” West says.

More like this

Editorial: Long overdue!

OPINION: The Government's latest move to make freshwater farm plans more practical and affordable is welcome, and long overdue.

Featured

Langfords crowned Share Farmers of the Year

As the New Zealand Dairy Industry Awards night unfolded, it became evident that Waikato’s Thomas and Fiona Langford were the frontrunners for the biggest prize of the night – the 2025 Share Farmers of the Year award.

ANZCO Foods' net profit plunges

Meat processor ANZCO Foods’ net profit has plunged on the back of lower market returns which squeezed margins and impacted business performance.

Editorial: Forest for the trees?

OPINION: Most people will be aware of the Government's plans to boost coal, oil and gas production to meet energy requirements.

National

Machinery & Products

Iconic TPW Woolpress turns 50!

The company behind the iconic TPW Woolpress, which fundamentally changed the way wool is baled in Australia and New Zealand,…