fbpx
Print this page
Thursday, 26 August 2021 07:55

Editorial: Upton was right

Written by  Staff Reporters
Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment Simon Upton. Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment Simon Upton.

OPINION: The infallibility of Overseer – the tool farmers have been required to use to measure nutrient loss – has come crashing down following a report by a special science advisory panel.

The panel managed to get access to the base data that supports this software model, which is owned jointly by MPI, AgResearch and the Fertiliser Association of NZ.

For a long time, farmers and many others have been questioning the veracity of Overseer. Horticulturalists in particular have pleaded with councils and the courts that the tool does not suit their needs. Their pleas have been ignored.

Credit must go to the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment, Simon Upton, who in 2018 conducted his own review into Overseer. He didn’t have the benefit of the data the science advisory panel had this time, but clearly saw the weaknesses in Overseer and drew it to the attention of the Government and the public.

There is no doubt that Overseer is a useful tool, but clearly its scientific value has been over-estimated by all and sundry. The company which owns it says Overseer still says it is doing what it is designed to do. The answer to that is probably yes – it helps some farmers estimate nutrient loss – but to use it as a legal tool is a bridge too far.

Farmers rightly argue that they have spent millions of dollars trying to stop Overseer being used as a regulatory tool and have got nowhere. They should rightly feel aggrieved.

But the problems don’t end there. What are the alternatives? Will an upgraded Overseer be ready in time to legally monitor the essential freshwater reforms? Will the Government revert to putting in rules such as the EU has, which are input rather than outcome-based?

The report, which is excellent, has now just added to the uncertainty that farmers and councils face in trying to implement all the changes in the pipeline.

Will we see legal challenges to Horizons’ One Plan and how will the courts now deal with future plans? It seems that, for the moment at least, Overseer’s days as a regulatory tool are over.

Thank you Simon Upton for your persistence!

More like this

Featured

Students' Strobe Light Targets Nesting Birds in Tractors

During the nesting season, from September to December, industrious starlings can quickly build nests in the darker areas behind tractor and vehicle, usually close to hot engines, typically resulting in localised damage or in some cases complete write-offs.

NZ Tractor Deliveries Up 5% Year to Date to September

With the last couple of months having seen some potential tractor purchases put on hold with the impending election and continued input cost rises, year-to-date figures, ending September, has seen deliveries up around 5% over the same period in 2025, with a total of 2026 units.

MPI's Diana Reaich on Non-Tariff Barriers and Trade Access

The head of the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) trade and international relations group says New Zealand is well-positioned to secure trade access and compete internationally as the world becomes more complicated, demanding and uncertain.

National

Machinery & Products

Claas Balers Turn 30

Claas built its first variable chamber round baler - the Variant 100 - in 1996, so 2026 marks 30 years…