increase font size
Paul Paynter says the industry's chronic labour shortage has been caused by a combination of Government naivety and its failure to get more RSE workers into NZ earlier.
The horticulture sector's worker shortage is Government-made, according to leading Hawke's Bay orchardist Paul Paynter.
He's a fourth generation orchardist and director of Yummy Fruit company, which produces apples, pears and stone fruit.
Paynter says the labour shortage has been caused by a combination of naïve optimism on the part of the Government and its failure to get more RSE workers into NZ earlier.
"The Government's lifting of the cap on RSE workers to 16,000 was an untimely call," he told Rural News.
"Nice to hear, but frustrating because although it was the right decision, it was made six months too late."
Paynter says during this and the past season they struggled to prune and thin trees and this "crisis" could have been alleviated if the Government had acted on the advice of the industry, which was to bring in more RSE workers ASAP.
He says it seems the Government's policy has been driven by ideology rather than pragmatism.
"They seem to think that all migrant labour is a by-word for exploitation and this isn't the case at all," he adds.
"We have a terrific record and are always told how good we are in our pastoral care and the way we look after our boys. We put a lot of effort into getting it right."
Paynter says, if he was in charge, he would have freed up the travel bubbles to the Pacific Islands and brought in as many workers as possible.
He says there are labour shortages in many sectors - including construction - and the RSE workers are very skilled people who can do more than just pick fruit.
"They have worked in the building industry back home and have a range of skills - including tiling, painting and carpet laying."
Paynter believes if the Government had heeded advice from the industry - and acted quickly - there wouldn't be the current problems, which are causing much unnecessary stress and disruption.
A Hawke's Bay apple orchardist supports the Government's objective of doubling exports but says this won't happen in the horticulture sector unless there's a change in the process for bringing new plant material into the country.
Nearly three years on from Cyclone Gabrielle, Hawke's Bay apple orchardist Paul Paynter says they are still doing remedial work around their orchards and facing financial challenges.
A Hawke's Bay apple grower says it's no longer profitable for him to export apples to the US because of the 15% tariff imposed on them by Donald Trump.
Many companies are financially mortally wounded by the effects of Cyclone Gabrielle and may have to sell up because of their high debt levels.
Just on two years ago Cyclone Gabrielle wreaked havoc in Hawke's Bay causing massive damage to NZ's largest apple growing region.
Central Otago District Council (CODC) has voted against a plan to spread treated sewage sludge from Cromwell and Alexandra on farmland near Lauder, a decision Federated Farmers says reflects strong opposition from rural residents.
Pāmu has released its FY26 Integrated Annual Report, reporting a Net Operating Profit of $113 million, more than double the $49 million recorded in FY25.
Meat Industry Association data, released alongside the Red Meat Sector conference in Wellington, shows export value climbing across the US, China, UK and Canada.
Applications are set to open for the 2027 Zanda McDonald Award, a trans-Tasman award recognised for identifying and fast-tracking talented young leaders in agriculture and agribusiness.
The Royal New Zealand College of General Practitioners (the College) and Hauora Taiwhenua Rural Health Network are calling for investment in a proposed new training pathway for rural GPs, warning that many rural practices are struggling to recruit while a large share of the existing workforce nears retirement.
Synlait has swung to second-half profit as operations stabilise, but the dairy processor still posted a $75.4m annual loss.
