Proposed new environmental rules for the Waimakariri District will drive some farmers off their land, say farmers and their support groups.
Professor Phil Jordan, a specialist in catchment science who recently visited New Zealand, is running a scheme measuring N and P loss on Irish farms nationwide to ensure farmers stick to European Union environment rules. The EU sets the basic regulations and then each country overlays these with its own special requirements.
The research, by the Irish agricultural research organisation Teagasc, covers a range of different catchments.
“There are two catchments in Country Wexford – one arable and one grassland – the latter on an impermeable soil type. There is a catchment in Country Cork which is a permeable soil type – that’s the main dairy catchment. Others are in County Louth, County Mayo and one near Drumlin with unique soils. Each catchment is about 10km2.”
Professor Jordan says the regulations are working, as shown by results on a dairy farm in County Cork, monitored for five years. Its high phosphorous index has fallen in that time.
Financial incentives or disincentives apply to farmers, depending on their compliance. For example, farmers who fail to meet their targets could lose their ‘single farm payment’ subsidy.
“So if a farmer has a high P test in his soil above a certain concentration then he is not allowed, under the regulations, to apply a chemical fertiliser. So he can actually incur a soil deficit on those soils because he is only allowed to use his own organic nutrients. So what we are seeing is a decrease in the soil nutrient test in those high P fields down towards an optimum and it’s the optimum that’s required in the regulations. The intensive farmer is required to farm at an optimum P concentration. It’s a big and complex continuum of soils right down to the streams system and we think that’s going to take a bit longer for the phosphorous changes to emerge.”
Jordan says while the regulations are designed to improve water quality, there is also a provision in them that it should not have a negative financial impact on the farmer. He has seen a slight increase in stock numbers which he hints means farmers are managing their environmental footprint successfully. But as in New Zealand the new regulations require farmers to do a lot more data collection to meet the requirements.
Department of Agriculture inspectors visit farms in the catchments and look how the farm is being managed, e.g. slurry holding tanks are noted and soil tests done.
Jordan prefers a ‘top-down bottom-up’ approach to measuring environmental standards.