Sir Lockwood Smith: Treat Agricultural Emissions Differently
Treat agricultural emissions differently. That’s the message from the chair of the prestigious Riddet Institute, Sir Lockwood Smith.
Mike Joy has forever been an outspoken commentator on environmental matters, and many of his views have irked farmers and pleased others.
OPINION: Sir Lockwood Smith has clearly and succinctly defined what academic freedom is all about, the boundaries around it and the responsibility that goes with this privilege.
Yes, it allows academics to speak out freely within the boundaries of the law, but it’s not a licence to make questionable, outrageous statements and physically threaten people.
Mike Joy has forever been an outspoken commentator on environmental matters, and many of his views have irked farmers and pleased others. He, like some academics, has used this freedom to the limit and that is his right. But it’s clear that his latest outburst of suggesting that dairy industry CEOs could be “hanged” for, in Joy’s opinion, allowing babies to be harmed by dairy farming, is way outside the realm and boundaries of academic freedom.
What’s worse, his initial response to Federated Farmers criticism was that it was “tongue in cheek”. Next time Joy is at any airport and, ‘tongue in cheek’, says to security officers ‘there’s a bomb in my bag’, guess what will happen – quite a few nights at his majesty’s lockup and more!
Threats are no longer seen as a joking matter and can often lead to nutters picking up the narrative and doing the deed. Feds are right to challenge Joy and the university and many are now rightly questioning why Victoria didn’t take some immediate action other than working through internal HR processes.
The vice chancellor of the university has rightly apologised for Joy’s comments, but he needs to be aware this is more than just an over-the-top remark, rather it’s close to a threat to kill – a crime – and surely deserves more than an apology.
One wonders what the reaction of people such as Mike Joy might be if farmers, tongue in cheek, suggested academics should be hung for their comments about farming. Maybe the university needs to call Sir Lockwood for some sage advice.
Northland farmer Greg Collins has taken over as chair of the Fonterra Co-operative Council.
The head of global dairy organisation, International Dairy Federation (IDF) is calling for accurate use of ‘dairy' term.
Be alert but not alarmed about El Niño. That’s the message from Professor Danny Donaghy, deputy head of the Massey University’s school of agriculture and the environment.
Farmers opposing rural trader Farmlands’ investment in AgriZeroNZ are warning the co-operative board not to brush away their concerns.
Farmers will wait it out like the rest of the country as the composition of the incoming government remains up in the air.
The International Dairy Federation’s World Dairy Summit has returned to New Zealand after sixteen years.
OPINION: It seems Canterbury processor Synlait is still in the doldrums.
OPINION: Get offside with New Zealand First leader Winston Peters at your own peril.