Thursday, 28 January 2021 10:55

Editorial: A stupid version of lotto

Written by  Peter Burke
New Zealand has been living off the back of its scientists. New Zealand has been living off the back of its scientists.

OPINION: There used to be a phrase that stated that ‘NZ lived off the sheep’s back’.

That was a myth — just like the nonsensical ‘No 8 wire’ concept.

The reality is that NZ lives off the back of our scientists who have created new plant and grass varieties, breeds and types of sheep and cattle that thrive in our climate. Not forgetting farm machinery and systems that have made NZ one of the best and most profitable farmed landscapes in the world.

Most of the science that achieved these gains was done before someone decided to ‘reform’ the science system, dismember the Ministry of Agriculture and DSIR and create things called CRI’s.

The primary sector is now at a crisis point because successive governments have allowed the funding of agricultural science to almost disappear. They have done this by creating a so called ‘competitive’ system, where highly-skilled scientists are expected to go begging for funds to some high-falutin science board and respond, at times, to some bizarre requests for proposals.

Competitive sounds nice and gives the impression that the system is efficient and that good science is being delivered. However, this is a myth!

When highly-skilled scientists have to spend up to 50% of their time writing up bids, that means that they only have 50% left to do the work. Is that a bureaucratic definition of efficiency? And what about the cost of the large departments in the CRI’s and universities dedicated to peer reviewing these bids before they leave the organisation?

The science money it seems is going to pen pushers – not the men and women in lab coats.

There is no longer a dedicated pool of funding for agriculture like there used to be, so ag scientists have to compete for money from a large pool – which funds universities, social science, medical science and god knows what else. Where is agriculture?

The primary sector has for too long been treated like a second-class citizen by all political parties, yet in the Covid environment, we hear Jacinda Ardern saying the saving grace for NZ is its ag sector. Well, show us the money! 

Megan Woods, as science minister, needs to completely overhaul the system and cut out the misnamed competitive system and give agriculture a fair slice of the funds. And specifically, give our highly-skilled ag scientists more time to spend in their laboratories rather than playing the lotto science funding game.

Peter Burke is the founder and life member of Science Communicators Association of NZ (SCANZ).

More like this

Chicken Little

OPINION: If you're one of the few still reading the NZ Herald, you'd have seen Chicken Little academics screaming that the sky is falling because Judith Collins has focused Marsden science grants on actual science.

Science 'deserves more funding'

A committee which carried out the review into New Zealand's science system says the underinvestment will continue to compromise the country's future.

Featured

Gongs for best field days site

Among the regular exhibitors at last month’s South Island Agricultural Field Days, the one that arguably takes the most intensive preparation every time is the PGG Wrightson Seeds site.

Feed help supplements Canterbury farmers meet protein goals

Two high producing Canterbury dairy farmers are moving to blended stockfeed supplements fed in-shed for a number of reasons, not the least of which is to boost protein levels, which they can’t achieve through pasture under the region’s nitrogen limit of 190kg/ha.

National

Machinery & Products

Buhler name to go

Shareholders at a special meeting have approved a proposed deal that will see Buhler Industries, the publicly traded Versatile and…

Grabbing bales made quick and easy

Front end loader and implement specialist Quicke has introduced the new Unigrip L+ and XL+ next-generation bale grabs, designed for…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Risky business

OPINION: In the same way that even a stopped clock is right twice a day, economists sometimes get it right.

Should've waited

OPINION: The proposed RMA reforms took a while to drop but were well signaled after the election.

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter