Monday, 04 August 2014 16:05

Editorial - The politics of slagging

Written by 

FISH & Game NZ’s use in March of dubious survey results to justify slagging dairy farming prompted Rural News  to urge farmers to ‘lock the gate’ to F&G members until the parent body shut up.

 

We reasoned that since Fish & Game’s governing body had such low regard for farming, it might want members even to forgo any association with farmers – by declining to hunt or fish on the properties of such scoundrels.

 A serious call, yes. But we demanded, and we still demand, an end to Fish & Game’s incessant anti-farming carping.

Conservation Minister Nick Smith recently fell foul of the lobby; it demanded Smith resign, accusing him of threatening the group’s future. The minister reportedly told the F&G council “Fish and Game sometimes behaves like a rabid NGO,” which it does.

But Smith rejects accusations that he told Fish & Game members, at a tense meeting in July, essentially to pull back on campaigning or risk its council being stripped of its statutory powers. 

In fact he wants Fish & Game to engage more with agriculture and irrigation so as to achieve the highest possible freshwater quality.

“While it is right for them to advocate for freshwater, they sometimes get into being anti New Zealand’s most important industry, the dairy industry.”

Smith in his defence released a DOC official’s notes of the meeting, including, “F&G needs to work out what it wants to be: a statutory body [with] legislation and a relationship with Government, or an NGO.”

Fish & Game is supposed to be an independent body with statutory authority to protect rivers, lakes and streams and the sole agency issuing hunting and fishing licences.

Rural News agrees with the Taxpayers’ Union which says, “The Fish and Game council’s campaigning is a gross breach of faith by a statutory body.” 

Enough is enough! If Fish & Game wants to be in politics, the Government should abolish compulsory licences for trout fishing and hunting, by which the lobby funds its political grandstanding. 

Featured

RSE Scheme Changes Coming - McClay

Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has admitted that a scheme bringing workers from Pacific nations to work on orchards has become too hard to navigate but says changes are coming.

Andy Macfarlane Joins AgriZeroNZ Board

Canterbury farmer Andy Macfarlane has been appointed to the board of AgriZeroNZ, the public-private partnership designed to accelerate the development and deployment of emissions reduction tools for New Zealand farmers.

National

Machinery & Products

 

 

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

True Reflection?

A fair question has been raised about how member-funded organisations should conduct themselves when taking a public position on any…

Civil Circus!

OPINION: It really is getting harder to lampoon government bureaucrats when they do such a good job of it themselves.…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter