Thursday, 21 December 2023 15:25

Bob's Blog: Going topless

Written by  Bob Campbell MW

OPINION: A year or so ago I congratulated Waiheke wine producer Destiny Bay for removing capsules from their bottles.

“Going topless”, as Destiny Bay owner and winemaker Sean Spratt explained, involved a certain amount of risk.

Destiny Bay produces some of this country’s most expensive wines and their customers are largely conservative wine drinkers. Would the loss of a capsule represent a loss in perceived value?

“We were a little bit on the leading edge,” says Sean. “People are still mystified about the purpose of capsules, which was to stop the corks being eaten by rats, cockroaches and weevils during long-term storage. That is simply not a problem today.”

Capsules were originally made of lead but these were banned to eliminate the risk of lead-oxide poisoning. Lead capsules were replaced by tin and plastic capsules which are expensive and pose environmental risk.

“We needed to educate the members of our Patron’s Club. Most came back with comments like ‘that’s a bold move; well done’, but we did get some push-back from a few of our members. Fortunately, we carried stocks of capsules and were able to apply them for customers who insisted on a ‘fully dressed’ wine.”

The long-term solution involves teaching wine drinkers that topless is fully dressed, he says. “Everywhere I travel in the world I see an increasing number of wines going topless. Once you understand the history of wine capsules and the negative benefits it is hard to justify applying them, so why bother?”

More like this

Mr Grumpy: Comparative Tastings

OPINION: Comparative Tastings are an expensive but potentially effective strategy for a wine producer to raise the image of their wine or wines.

Bob's Blog: Snail Scourge

OPINION: I have a 50% share in a vineyard and for the first time ever, snails are threatening to decimate my crop.

Top Wineries of New Zealand

Bannockburn producer Felton Road has been named Winery of the Year New Zealand 2024 by The Real Review, a list compiled by New Zealand wine critics Bob Campbell MW, Huon Hooke, and Stephen Wong MW.

Drops of God

OPINION: Drops of God is a mini-series about a large wine inheritance and the civilised battle between a Japanese wine enthusiast, Issei, and a French woman whose nose bleeds when she tastes wine.

» Latest Print Issues Online


Biosecurity - Our Responsibility

Biosecurity - Our Responsibility

OPINION: The news could not have been more concerning – an industry member deliberately and illegally imported grapevines into New…

Editorial: Vintage Perspectives

Editorial: Vintage Perspectives

OPINION: In this edition we check out vintage perspectives from around New Zealand, with many reporting lighter than typical yields…

Popular Reads

Sustainability Success

Taking two sustainability awards at two events on a single evening felt like "true recognition" of the work Lawson's Dry…

H2Ortigator - the plant babysitter

A New Zealand startup is offering a novel approach to irrigation and nutrition management, specifically designed to optimise the growth…

Marlborough's Small Town Winery

Marlborough’s 2024 vintage was “a return to form for Marlborough summers”, says Astrolabe General Manager Libby Levett.