Thursday, 13 February 2025 11:55

Deer farmer targets poor performers, saves money

Written by  Nigel Malthus
Stu Stokes (left) explains some of his deer weaning and management practises during a field day on his farm at Sheffield. Stu Stokes (left) explains some of his deer weaning and management practises during a field day on his farm at Sheffield.

Management practices that aim to cull the poor performers rather than boost the best are a key to success for Canterbury deer farmer Stu Stokes.

Stokes runs a red deer venison and velvet operation on a 240ha block at Sheffield which has been in the family since 1987. He took it over about 2000, adding a nearby 140ha “top block” in 2001.

He recently hosted a weaning management field day on the farm, which was organised by the local Deer Farmers Association branch and the Deer Industry Association of New Zealand (DINZ). The event attracted about 80 attendees.

It is not a stud but a purely commercial farm and is run accordingly, Stokes said.

This year he will be wintering about 900 stags, 600 in-calf hinds, 160 weaner stags and 270 weaner hinds.

“Deer were always my passion, and hinds were always to me the powerhouse behind it,” he said.

Stokes said he has dyslexia but the power of that was it lets him think outside the box, with a lot of things on farm done quite differently. He also runs a lot of custom machinery of his own design.

“My focus is probably more on the bottom 10% of anything. So, I don’t really care about my top producing stags.

“It’s the bottom 10% of your operation that’s costing you money.”

Stokes weans before the rut, aiming to have weaning complete by February 25, with mating due to start on March 9.

With the herd currently running on his top block, he will wean about 200 to 250 a day, getting them down to the home yards by trailer.

“All we do with them down there is we drench some with a drench and magnesium. We don’t do any tagging, we don’t do any vaccinating, or anything like that. I think, the poor wee sods, it’s a stressful enough day for them as it is.”

Because he sells no weaners immediately, vaccination and tagging can wait until the next time they’re in the yard.

But that first visit is when Stokes’ liking for doing things his own way kicks in, with his own method of identifying the poor performers of the herd.

He says that in each weaner mob of about 250, there might be eight to 10 “potlickers, tail-enders, runts, you name it."

They are identified and held aside, then have their heads painted with a sticky blob of Milkeeze udder cream mixed with food grade blue dye, then are returned to the hinds.

“Those little pot lickers will go and find mum, diving underneath for a feed, and they’ll actually stain the whole belly blue.”

The hinds so identified will then be culled.

Stokes says they choose fawns that are not merely late born, because late born fawns should still be outstanding even though they’re small.

“These things aren’t. They’re rough in the coat, they’ve struggled.

“My theory behind it is that we get a lot more mastitis and a lot more other issues in hinds than we’re willing to acknowledge. The indicator of that is that they haven’t produced a decent fawn.”

He says the identified hinds turn out to be the oddest-looking of the herd, all with some kind of issue.

“It’s amazing how accurate it is. If I put out nine fawns head painted, I’ll put money on it - I’ll get nine hinds back.

“And if I’ve only got eight I’ll guarantee you one of them is a set of twins.”

Stokes said it helps to “lift the bar” on his herd performance.

“Every year we do it. We’re not talking big numbers, but it tidies up those poor producing hinds.”

He has never kept any of those hinds to confirm that they would produce another runt in subsequent years, but says this year he may ask the vets to check their udders at slaughter.

“I know the milking platforms are discovering a lot more quarters that aren’t working and that sort of stuff.”

Small Hinds

Stu Stokes is happy to run small hinds, 52 to 55kg, which he calls the “Perendales or Jerseys” of the deer world.

He sells them off after three calvings.

He said there was a market for small productive hinds on finishing farms.

“They know they can put a decent-sized stag over them and end up with a decent weaner but they’ve got a small hind with a good nature.

“I have no hinds here that are going to be calved for the fourth time. They’re all gone. We’ve done it that way for, must be, nearly 10 years.”

further trick he recommends is to drive into the paddock of weaners a few days after weaning and very quietly follow them around, idling in first gear. It naturally prompts the animals to learn to stick together without individuals bolting.

“It’s amazing how they change. They develop into a mob and you can actually move them as a mob.

“I’ll do that two or three times with a mob before I ever decide to try to shift them. Once you’ve done this, they actually hold together really well.”

More like this

BVD Control in Dairy Herds: How to Find & Remove PI Animals

Bovine Viral Diarrhoea (BVD) is estimated to cost New Zealand's dairy and beef industries more than $150 million every year, yet many of the tools needed to control it are already well understood. After more than 25 years in veterinary practice, Andrew Weir, animal health technical specialist at LIC, has seen firsthand the impact BVD can have on herd performance. We asked him about the role of persistently infected (PI) animals and the practical steps farmers can take to reduce their risk.

Transition Period: The Make-or-Break Window for Dairy Cows

The transition period is the make-or-break window for your entire season. If this period is poorly managed, you don't just see a few downer cows, you see a downward spiral that affects the cow's health, production and reproduction long into the season.

Managing Light Ewes at Scanning: Wormwise Advice

Scanning is a great time to start identifying and managing groups of ewes based on feeding priorities. Wormwise's Mary Bowron discusses some of the possible reasons ewes lose condition in early winter - and it's not necessarily internal parasites.

Scour Prevention in Calves

Healthy, well-grown calves are the building blocks of any future dairy herd. Giving them the best start to life is crucial, and the primary strategy to reduce the burden of disease caused by rotavirus infection is vaccination.

Featured

Editorial: The Price of Progress

OPINION: Alistair Carmichael raises some interesting questions about striking a balance between profitability in farming and preserving the character of rural communities.

NZ Ploughing Champions' Gear Stuck at Sea Before Worlds

Ploughing champions Mark Dillon and Malcolm Taylor earned the right to represent the country at the World Ploughing Championships in Osijek, Croatia, on 5 and 6 September, after winning their titles at the New Zealand Ploughing Championships in Middlemarch in 2025.

National

Machinery & Products

 

 

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

True Reflection?

A fair question has been raised about how member-funded organisations should conduct themselves when taking a public position on any…

Civil Circus!

OPINION: It really is getting harder to lampoon government bureaucrats when they do such a good job of it themselves.…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter