Tuesday, 16 June 2020 10:50

Nitrogen caps bound to fail

Written by  David Anderson
Soil scientist Doug Edmeades says the European approach of implementing environmental policy based on controlling inputs will not work in NZ. Soil scientist Doug Edmeades says the European approach of implementing environmental policy based on controlling inputs will not work in NZ.

The Government’s decision to cap nitrogen fertiliser inputs at 190 kg N/ha per year is doomed to fail because it ignores basic science, claims soil scientist Doug Edmeades.

These limitations were announced as part of the new freshwater regulations unveiled by Environment Minister David Parker last month.

Edmeades claims if nitrogen fertiliser is capped there are two likely outcomes. “Farmers will simply import more supplementary feed to maintain production, and/or the clover component in the pasture, and the amount of fixed nitrogen, will increase, compensating for any decline in nitrogen fertiliser use.”

He says that when an animal urinates, it applies nitrogen at the rate of about 500 to 1000 kg N/ha. 

“This is too much for the pasture and soil to accommodate and hence results in a huge excess of soluble nitrogen in a localised spot of soil, which is then subject to leaching into waterways,” Edmeades explains. “It is for these reasons that animal urine patches are the source of most (about 95%) of the nitrogen getting into waterways.” 

He adds that the key to controlling the amount of nitrogen leached is to control the number and frequency of urine patches, especially in the autumn/early winter period. 

Edmeades says there are three sources of nitrogen in the animals’ diet and in their urine.

“The largest is the clover nitrogen. Clover is a legume and it converts atmospheric nitrogen into plant protein,” he says. “This ‘fixed N’ feeds the soil with nitrogen, which is taken up by companion grasses.”

Edmeades says the other two sources of nitrogen come onto the farm either as nitrogen fertiliser or the nitrogen in supplementary feeds. 

“Either way the total amount of nitrogen in the soil/plant/animal system will remain unchanged. Therefore, the amount of urine N – and hence nitrogen leaching – will remain the same,” he claims. 

“Water quality will not be improved. The proposed nitrogen fertiliser cap is technically flawed.”

Edmeades says he thought New Zealand had rejected the European approach of implementing environmental policy based on controlling inputs. 

“Our approach was, I thought, to be focused on managing outputs.”

Edmeades says the difference between the two concepts is important because the goal is to change on-farm behaviour to improve water quality. 

“The input controllers say cap fertiliser nitrogen. If that does not work then we have to control something else – like capping stock numbers, getting rid of all fertilisers, or reducing farming activity,” he explains. 

“The output control approach sets limits on the concentration of nitrogen in waterways. With the limit set, the farmer can do whatever he likes on the farm providing the freshwater N goal is achieved.”

Edmeades believes this approach encourages inventiveness and entrepreneurship and allows the farmer to think of other options. 

“Like putting the animals in a herd home, especially during the rainy season, so that the urine can be collected and returned to the soil at an appropriate agronomic rate,” he says. 

“Or, tile drain the flats so that the nitrogen moving down through the soil is intercepted, captured and returned to the soil.” 

Edmeades claims the difference between the input and output method is between progress or extreme environmentalism. 

More like this

Carbon zero milk

Fonterra has joined forces with a supermarket chain to deliver what it claims is NZ’s first carbon zero milk.

Winners committed to environment

It's not the first time Fonterra’s John Wilson Memorial Trophy recipients, Nick and Nicky Dawson have been recognised for their sustainability efforts.

Sustainability stars pick up awards

Ten kiwi dairy farmers who have shown exceptional care for the environment have been recognised with a DairyNZ sustainability and stewardship award.


Miraka unhappy with rushed DIRA changes

Miraka chief executive, Richard Wyeth says the company was disappointed at the way the Dairy Industry Restructuring Act Bill (DIRA) was rushed through Parliament recently.


Limited feed puts ewes at risk

Severe feed shortages in parts of the country mean many ewes are on a nutritional knife-edge heading into lambing and could be at risk of developing metabolic disorders.


A ticking time bomb

Our dairy industry risks being exposed to a ‘ticking time bomb’ of unethical players unlawfully passing off New Zealand-made and…

Nervous wait for winter

The unknown of what winter will bring is very much on the mind of the Hawkes Bay Rural Support Trust…

Be careful, Potatoes NZ!

Moves by the NZ potato industry to have anti-dumping tariffs imposed on European imports could play into the hands of…

China keeps dairy prices high

Whole milk powder (WMP) prices are now sitting above pre-Covid-19 levels and New Zealand farmers can thank a resurging Chinese…

Machinery & Products

Hydrogen excavator a first

While most motive industries are focused on hybrid or EV power plants, JCB has developed the construction industry’s first hydrogen-powered…

Jack’s unique solution

Jason Jack was left with severe spinal injuries after a wakeboarding accident when he was 29, but that hasn’t stopped…

HP and digital tech combo

The latest New Holland T8 GENESIS is said to capitalise on the productive combinations of Stage V horsepower and digital…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Spell check

Your old mutt was not surprised to see the NZ Dairy Industry Awards hastily remove the title of this year’s…

About time!

Your canine crusader has been a long-time critic of NZ governments – of all stripes – who, for the past…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter