Tuesday, 30 June 2020 10:55

Regenerative ag’s ‘mythology’ questioned

Written by  David Anderson
Lincoln University’s Professor Derek Moot is concerned at the lack of scientific evidence to back claims made about regenerative agriculture. Lincoln University’s Professor Derek Moot is concerned at the lack of scientific evidence to back claims made about regenerative agriculture.

The “mythology” of regenerative agriculture and lack of scientific evidence has prompted two renowned plant scientists to write to Ag Minister Damien O’Connor.

In the letter, Lincoln University’s Professor Derek Moot and retired plant scientist Professor Warwick Scott, express their concerns about the increased profile of regenerative agriculture in New Zealand media and farming sectors. 

They have called on the minister to convene an expert panel of scientists to review all the claims made about practice. 

“It is important that sound science drives our agricultural systems,” they say. “We believe such a panel should provide a robust critique of the claims made about ‘regenerative agriculture’ to ensure the public, industry and policy makers have a balanced and scientifically informed view of the ideas promulgated.”

Both Scott and Moot say regenerative agriculture has gained highly favourable publicity, but with no critical scientific evaluation. They believe this lack of critical evaluation is potentially damaging to the current world leading agricultural practices used by sheep and beef farmers in NZ. 

“The underpinning scientific principles of our current agricultural systems are in danger of being devalued by a system that we believe has several serious short-comings,” writes the pair in their letter. 

“We are particularly concerned that the erroneous publicity about ‘regenerative agriculture’ will divert the limited NZ agricultural science resources from more important, substantive issues.”

Scott and Moot claim that regenerative agriculture has become an all-embracing term to encompass the practices of any individual who does not want to be seen to be using conventional agricultural techniques. 

“Importantly, this lack of definition, by default, implies that current conventional agriculture, as practiced in NZ, is degenerative.

“We strongly reject this implication. Our current sheep and beef farming practices are world leading. We recognise that there are practices and practitioners in conventional agriculture that can be improved, but

consider these are minor compared with most international production systems.”

The pair point to the fact that NZ’s sheep beef sector is the only industry to have reduced its greenhouse gas emissions intensity to below 1990s levels, while continuing to achieve strong productivity gains. 

Scott and Moot say the emergence of regenerative agriculture has arisen from unsustainable farming practices in Australia and North America. 

“However, this does not mean the practice is required, relevant or useful in the context of NZ’s climates, soils and agricultural systems.”

They also express concern by acceptance of regenerative agriculture by the Primary Sector Council (promoted by O’Connor) and the B+LNZ.

“We accept there is a strong lobby group behind this (regenerative ag) advocacy, in a similar manner to the organic community, the anti vax movement and anti-1080 lobby,” the letter says. 

“However, we are convinced this system lacks credibility and contains many aspects that are scientifically untenable. We believe it is our statutory duty as academics to provide some warning about the fallibility of these systems.”

Sound familiar?

Scott and Moot believe a similar “wave of hype” around regenerative agriculture also happened with organics.

“Organic agriculture has been promoted since the 1980s to provide an ‘alternative’ production system for food,” their letter tells O’Connor. 

However, the pair say organic’s promises have not been realised. 

“In Europe, where it has been most strongly promoted, meta-analyses of production systems across a range of arable, horticultural and pastoral enterprises show an average 20% drop in production. As a result, only 6% of current European production is organic because

businesses cannot make a profit from this lowered production and increased labour input, even with heavy financial subsidies. This is why organic production has and will continue to be a cottage industry aimed at a local market in most countries.”

Scott and Moot believe that the emergence of regenerative agriculture is following a similar path to that of organics. 

More like this

Scientists criticise latest 'US fad'

New Zealand agriculture doesn't need "the latest fad from America," according to New Zealand Institute of Agricultural and Horticultural Science (NZIAHS) president, Jon Hickford.

PhD Précis: Jess Ryder

Climate change is likely to impact on the regionally distinct microbial communities in New Zealand vineyards and wineries, says PhD student Jess Ryder.

PhD Précis

From tasting the world’s hottest chilis to analysing grapevine phenology, Ghouse Peera has long been fascinated with plants.




Alliance pays back wage subsidy

After being dogged by claims about its entitlement to the wage subsidy, the country’s largest meat processor will now fully…

Gone Fishing

Late last year, Farmlands chief executive Peter Reidie announced he’d resigned to take on a new job heading up Sanfords…

Machinery & Products

Good growth year for Claas

While many sectors of the agricultural machinery were hit by the ravages of Covid-19, the effects of the pandemic did…

Green machine frugal on fuel

According to the industry respected independent DLG PowerMix test, John Deere appears to be the best choice of tractor for…

App takes pressure off

TRS Tyre & Wheel, owned by Trelleborg Wheel Systems, has introduced the TLC Plus App to the New Zealand market.

New MF 5S series arrives

Just before Christmas, Massey Ferguson quietly released details of the successor to its popular MF 5700S range in the shape…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound


Your old mate reckons the nomination of the New Zealand Dairy Industry Awards (NZDIA) management team as a finalists in…

Good riddance!

The Hound reckons 2021 is off to a rollicking start with news that professional whinger and anti-farming drone Martin Taylor…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter