Wednesday, 12 August 2020 06:55

RMA reform some time away

Written by  Peter Burke
Environment Minister David Parker recently released a report that says the RMA should be scrapped and replaced. Environment Minister David Parker recently released a report that says the RMA should be scrapped and replaced.

A leading planning academic says people are fixated on doing away with the Resource Management Act (RMA) when they should really be focusing on what its replacement might look like.

Associate Professor Caroline Miller of Massey University, who has spent a lifetime working in local government and resource management, says she was involved in local government when the RMA was introduced 30 years ago.

Recently, Environment Minister David Parker released a report by a panel headed by retired Appeal Court Judge Tony Randerson, which proposes that the RMA should be scrapped and replaced by two new laws – a Natural Built Environment Act and a Strategic Planning Act. 

Its recommendations include a proposal for each region in the country to put forward a combined development plan, consolidating the myriad of local council plans that currently exist.  The proposal would also see more power being given to Iwi. Parker says the RMA has doubled in size from its original length and become too costly, takes too long, and has not adequately protected the environment.

Miller says the proposal to scrap the existing RMA and effectively start again is revolutionary – just like developing the present RMA was 30 years ago. But she has some concerns about what is being proposed. 

Miller says a lot of the planning is going to be regional based. She believes a lot of local government structures are not necessarily set up to do the sort of big picture, collaborative style planning envisaged by the Government.

“In terms of rural interests there are couple of things that people might like to think about,” Miller told Rural News

“Certainly, there will be a lot of change in the area of water allocation because the report identifies that the ‘first come first served’ model is not necessarily the best one and I think a lot of people would agree with that. 

“However, I think the devil is in the detail and what do you replace it with? With climate change we are going to see much more competition for water especially as east coast areas become drier. We know from experience that what sounds wonderful on paper may be hard to implement,” she says.

Miller claims this is essentially the problem with the existing RMA. 

She says the Randerson report is trying to simplify the process and predicts there will be fewer consents required as these will be worked through in the regional plans. Miller adds the suggestion is that government will set bottom lines to preserve the environment and also bring in Maori concepts and Maori ways of doing things. 

She believes the new proposal has some potential, but it is going to take a lot of work to see how that is going to work at the coal face.

“The part that most people are more interested in is what is this going to mean for me on a day-to-day basis. What I believe everyone should be preparing themselves for is that it will be quite a long transition period,” Miller told Rural News

“The RMA will not just disappear one day and a new act come in the next day. I believe it will take a lot longer than people think to get the new legislation in place.”


One of Caroline Miller’s concerns is the trend to use independent commissioners instead of local elected councils to hear resource consent applications. 

She says this means that a small group of people are being given substantial powers and questions should be asked about that.

“They are talking about having much more uniform sets of plans around the country and central government will be much more involved than they have been in the past,” Miller told Rural News. “This means that, in some instances, communities may have less voice in shaping what happens in their areas.” 

Miller believes this is the case with the Government’s latest national policy statement on urban development and says if the same principles were applied to rural land use plans it could be quite challenging.

“It also means that central government is going to become much more involved in planning processes than they have in the last 30 years that we have had the RMA.” 

Miller says she’ll be intrigued to see what eventually happens and whether the Government accepts all the recommendations in the report.

More like this

No tears over RMA overhaul

News that the controversial Resource Management Act (RMA) is to get a complete overhaul has been welcomed by many primary sector organisations.

Parker dropped the EU FTA ball – Nats

Don’t blame the European Union for its “unacceptable” offer to NZ agriculture in current FTA negotiations, blame David Parker, says National's trade spokesman.



Fonterra back in the black

Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell says 2019/20 was a good year for the co-op, with profit up, debt down and a strong milk price.

Strategy to reduce heifer mastitis

First calvers are more prone to mastitis than older cows. According to DairyNZ, farmers must choose a strategy that best suits their herd, farm team, and budget.


Helping grow farming’s future

John Jackson’s ability for future and critical thinking saw him deeply involved in the development of an agribusiness programme that…

Nothing sustainable without profit

Chair of Dairy Environment Leaders programme Melissa Slattery believes that sustainable farming is highly important to young farmers.

Machinery & Products

JD updates header line-up

John Deere has updated its entire header line-up for combines to include the new HDR Rigid Cutterbar Drapers, RDF HydraFlex…

Hybrid harvesters launched

New Holland has entered the world of hybrid headers, launching a new machine that blends its conventional threshing drum and…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound


OPINION: This old mutt had to have a giggle at the dig Feds recently made at the Green Party in the…


OPINION: Your canine crusader was aghast to read that the prices of zucchini and cucumbers rose more than 30% in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter