Tuesday, 27 January 2026 11:55

Winston Peters' FTA attacks 'just dog whistling' - Jacobi

Written by  Peter Burke
New Zealand First Leader and Foreign Minister Winston Peters. New Zealand First Leader and Foreign Minister Winston Peters.

International trade expert Stephen Jacobi says Winston Peters' objections to the Indian free trade deal are "ridiculous".

The New Zealand First Leader and Foreign Minister says the free trade agreement with India gives too much away - especially on immigration - and does not return enough to NZ, especially dairy.

However, Jacobi says the FTA gives India some marginal improvements in immigration standards for skilled professionals and students, but by no means opens the floodgates. He says NZ is desperately in need of workers.

"He's just dog whistling and feels that he could have negotiated something better. Somehow, I doubt it," Jacobi told Rural News.

Peters says NZ First won't support the ratification of the NZ/India FTA when it comes before Parliament.

Again, Jacobi says such an attitude is beyond the pale. NZ First also didn't support the China FTA. He adds he has no idea what the Green Party will do. 

He says ideally there should be bipartisan support on trade deals such as this. What Peters is doing is "pure political nonsense".


Read More:


"How can he seriously continue as Foreign Minister and not supporting this FTA. India is a major foreign policy player and sooner or later he's going to have to meet his Indian counterpart and explain why the deal wasn't good enough. We'll just have to wait and see what happens," he says.

Finally, Jacobi says it would be appalling if the Labour Party didn't support the deal. He says although National wants to take the full credit for the FTA, in fact the early groundwork for it was done under Labour Trade Minister Damien O'Connor.

"So, it would be somewhat hypocritical if Labour didn't support the FTA," he says.

More like this

Good Ol' Days

OPINION: NZ First knows its market and feeds it a constant diet of how ‘good’ the good old days were, promising to resurrect policies and icons of a bygone era.

Lame Duck?

OPINION: The media is already playing the 'who will Winston choose?' game every time the polls show Labour and National neck and neck.

New Order

OPINION: If old Winston Peters thinks building trade relations with new nations, such as India, isn't a necessary investment in our future, he has rocks in his head.

Indian FTA

OPINION: Winston Peters' tirade against the free trade deal stitched with India may not be all political posturing by the wily politician.

Where is Luxon?

OPINION: Why can't Christopher Luxon stand up to Winston Peters over the latter’s high-profile attack on the proposed Indian FTA?

Featured

Rural Industry Leaders Event Raises $400,000

New Zealand’s rural sector has once again demonstrated its generosity, with the second Rural Industry Leaders Dinner, Debate and Auction raising an impressive $400,000 for the Rural Support Trust.

National

Machinery & Products

Look Beyond Features

Technology adoption on New Zealand dairy farms has accelerated rapidly over the past decade.

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

A Good Start

OPINION: While we're on the topic of lumberjacks, Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard has no doubt used a chainsaw hundreds of…

Smith V Fonterra

OPINION: To a chorus of crying greenies, and not a minute too soon, the Government has moved to put the…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter