Wednesday, 10 March 2021 17:55

Dubious politics at play

Written by  Owen Jennings
Farmers are already offsetting methane emissions. Farmers are already offsetting methane emissions.

OPINION: FARM (Facts About Ruminant Methane) is a group of farmers and scientists who question the need for drastic cuts in ruminant methane. Owen Jennings prosecutes FARM’s argument in the second of a two part opinion piece…


The other reason proponents, such as the Climate Change Commission, argue that we have to take actions is that methane is NZ’s big problem – because our livestock numbers are high relative to other GHG-producing activities – so we need to pull our weight and “do something”.

Answer:  We are already doing something. 

Our farmers are way ahead of the play.  They are already offsetting all the methane they produce by sequestering huge amounts of CO₂. Their grass, soil and other farm vegetation absorbs as much GHG as their cows and sheep produce.  All vegetation takes in CO₂ for photosynthesis. 

This balanced situation using the age-old natural carbon cycle separates farming from other GHG emitters who have no natural offset.  That is why farming should never be in the ETS or face any restrictions.

But wait there is more.

Of the one degree Celsius of warming we have recorded over the last 150 years, methane is allegedly responsible for a mere 10% -20% of this increase.  Some 40%, at least, of methane emissions are natural.  So, the effect of 10% reduction proposed by the Climate Change Commission makes no sense at all.  It is pitiful.

Hang about – it gets even worse still.  And it is going to get all complicated and ‘sciencey’.

GHGs operate in the electromagnetic spectrum.  Figure 1 (shows the radiation transmitted by the atmosphere as UV, visible light and Infrared radiation (see the yellow band in the figure). The left-hand side of the figure (left of the red dotted line) shows the region of incoming solar radiation (0.2 to 3 micrometres wavelength span). The right-hand side denotes the re-radiation from earth as long-wavelength infrared energy covering the 3 to 70 micrometre span. 

Each greenhouse gas is analysed separately in the lower part of the graph.  The width and height of each absorption peak for each gas is clearly shown. The height of the peak denotes the maximum amount of radiant energy that each gas can possibly absorb over that range of wavelengths. The width of each absorption band shows the precise wavelengths to which that the particular greenhouse gas responds.

It you examine each gas, you will see that methane, nitrous oxide, and ozone, only have a few narrow absorption bands with none absorbing 100% of any wavelength.  Even CO₂ has only four peaks where absorption is over 50% and these occur in narrow bands, meaning CO₂ absorbs little energy. 

Water vapour, in stark contrast, absorbs over a far wider range of wavelengths with three broad peaks of maximum 100% absorption and multiple small peaks.  Above about 18 micrometres water vapour absorbs 100% of outgoing infrared energy.

The published evidence shows that by far the dominant GHG absorbing solar radiation is water vapour.  The absorption potential of solar radiation by the other GHGs is minuscule or absent. 

From a farmer’s point of view, methane and nitrous oxide can clearly be ignored as having no appreciable effect on warming.

At a total only 0.012% of all the GHGs, or 0.00018% of the total atmosphere methane (and nitrous oxide) is physically incapable of impacting temperature. 

And we are going to beat our chests over a 0.13% reduction per year of something already unbelievably trivial and inconsequential. 

Time for a brain check, surely!

Even decimating our entire cow herd and all our sheep will not make any impact on temperature at all – so infinitesimal it could never be measured by the most effective measuring tool. 

Meanwhile, the Climate Change Commission and the Government put their collective heads in the sand over Article 2 of the Paris Accord.  Pretending we can cut the national herd by 15% plus other constraints, and not have a disastrous reduction in production and exports simply shows alarming ignorance.

One can only further conclude that something else is going on that isn’t science – virtue signalling by NZ leaders and dubious politics at international level.

More like this

Absurdity on steroids

OPINION: F.A.R.M. (Facts About Ruminant Methane) is a group of farmers and scientists who question the need for drastic cuts in ruminant methane. They argue that there is a natural cycle where the emitters of a GHG (methane) use as much as they emit to grow the grass the cows need to produce the methane and thus puts ruminant methane in a different category to fossil fuel emissions.  

Techno Expo gets off to a flyer

AN INAUGURAL Technology Expo run as part of Beef + Lamb New Zealand’s Central Otago ‘Farming For Profit’ programme has been hailed a success by organisers.

Healthy spring farm market

FARM SALES WERE up 47.3% (133 farms) for the three months ending November 2013, compared to the same period in the previous year, says the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand (REINZ).


Guy standing for Ravensdown

Former Agriculture Minister and Horowhenua dairy farmer Nathan Guy is standing for election to the Ravensdown board of directors.

Machinery & Products

Helps tame the wind!

Amazone's recently released WindControl System automatically monitors and adjusts the spreading pattern to compensate for the effect of the wind…

First Claas patent hits a century

While Claas has registered more than 3,000 patents during its 108-year history, the company is currently celebrating the 100th anniversary…

JD invests in robotics

Global giant Deere and Co has acquired Silicon Valley start-up company Bear Flag Robotics, which specialises in autonomous driving technologies…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Too many hits?

OPINION: Well-known professional protestor, John Minto has run off at the mouth without checking his facts.

Good question!

A mate of the Hound's thinks it was more than a bit dodgy when DairyNZ chair Jim van der Poel…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter