Wednesday, 31 January 2024 07:55

ODH collapse 'not a surprise'

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Organics sector leader Brendan Hoare says Organic Dairy Hub lacked the scale to compete in the global market. Organics sector leader Brendan Hoare says Organic Dairy Hub lacked the scale to compete in the global market.

An organic sector leader believes that failed farmer-owned co-operative Organic Dairy Hub (ODH) lacked the scale to compete in the global market.

Brendan Hoare, whose company Buy Pure NZ takes NZ organic products to the world, says he wasn't surprised at the collapse of ODH. Hoare also served as head of Organics Aotearoa, the national body of the organic sector.

Hoare says scale of operation is critical to success in the organics sector because of the benefits that go with it.

Smaller organic companies find it hard to compete with growing e-channel sales and online trade.

"Unless you are a boutique operation, small organic companies are finding it hard to remain viable," he told Rural News.

"ODH got caught in the middle; they were too small to be a boutique and not big enough to compete with the big players."

Despite ODH's collapse, Hoare believes organics remains a viable business for NZ firms.

While the growth in organics has slowed - from double digits in some cases to 2-4% per annum - Hoare points out that there's still growth.

ODH, touted as New Zealand's only 100% farmer-owned organic milk producer, was placed into voluntary liquidation last month. ODH collected milk daily from its farmer base, stretching from Northland to Wairarapa.

About 20% of that milk was turned into milk powders and nutritional products, processed at Waikato Innovation Park in Ruakura and generally exported to Australia and Asia, with some New Zealand customers as well.

It also produced Our's Truly brand liquid and UHT milk, cheese and milk powder using third party processors. The products were sold locally and exported.

According to the Companies Office, ODH directors, made up of farmers and independents, called in the liquidators, KPMG's Leon Bowker and Luke Norman, on December 1 last year.

In their first report, the liquidators say the company is being wound up after ceasing trading.

"After paying any remaining creditors, remaining funds will be distributed to shareholders. This is a solvent liquidation and will remain solvent for the period of liquidation."

ODH was formed by 37 organic dairy farmers, with a third based in Waikato.

On December 1 last year, ODH directors Michael Allen Brown, Cameron Farrand, Sharleen Gardner, John Wafer, Frank Goodin and Ian Cumming voted to liquidate the company.

A "statement of affairs", filed by the directors, shows that on November 24 last year, ODH had $50,000 in the bank. It had assets of $145,200, including cash at bank, $31,000 worth of stock, $54,000 in receivables and plant and equipment valued at $10,000.

Its only liability was $439 owed unsecured creditors, leaving the company with net assets worth $144,800.

The directors expect liquidator's costs to reach $20,000 plus another $35,000 for legal and consultancy.

ODH farmer suppliers have been recruited by Fonterra, which has a small organics business. This season, Fonterra hopes to process over 100 million litres of organic milk.

More like this

ODH out

OPINION: The future of Organic Dairy Hub, a small organic co-operative started by Waikato farmers, remains unclear, following well publicised financial difficulties.


Lower Aus exports, good news for NZ

Australia's dairy import and export mix is "slowly trading places" with export volumes falling sharply in recent years while imports have spiked, according to Rabobank.

Taylor-made for recovery

A year ago, Cyclone Gabrielle wreaked havoc at family-owned Taylors orchard and packhouse in Hawke's Bay.

Covid's urban/rural divide

According to a new study from the University of Otago, there was a visible rural/urban divide in Covid-19 vaccination rates.

Long-term plan needed

Well before Cyclone Gabrielle struck, Richard Burke was advocating for a long-term sustainable infrastructure plan for the Tairawhiti region.


An annual event?

Meat Industry Association chief executive, Sirma Karapeeva, says she hopes that National Lamb Day will now take place every year.

Selling the value of lamb

The meat industry has a job to sell the value proposition of lamb, says Agriculture Minister Todd McClay.

Winning back farmer trust

One year into her role as Beef + Lamb New Zealand chair, Kate Acland is continuing to work hard and…

Tough times on farm

Beef + Lamb New Zealand chair Kate Acland says while farmers are quite positive about the new Government, the economic…

Machinery & Products

Norwood's deal with SKY

Norwood has signed an exclusive New Zealand distribution agreement with the Burel Group for the SKY Agriculture brand.

Killing weed seeds in a single pass

John Deere's X-Series Combine Harvesters can now be complemented by the advanced weed control capability of Redekop’s Seed Control Unit…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Bureaucratic insanity

OPINION: The Hound reckons if farmers in this country think they've got a problem with the small-minded officious bureaucrats imposing…

Tone deaf?

OPINION: Your old mate can't believe the absolute brass neck of the directors at Beef + Lamb NZ who are…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter