Tuesday, 19 November 2024 08:55

Returns 'not good enough'

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Fonterra chair Peter McBride, Anya Wicks, director governance, risk and audit and outgoing director Leonie Guiney at the AGM last week. Fonterra chair Peter McBride, Anya Wicks, director governance, risk and audit and outgoing director Leonie Guiney at the AGM last week.

Fonterra leaders are making their case for offloading the co-operative's $3 billion consumer business, noting that its return on capital has been nowhere near respectable.

Speaking at the co-op's annual meeting in New Plymouth last week, both Fonterra chair Peter McBride and chief executive Miles Hurrell noted that shareholder approval is critical to the sale.

Fonterra's consumer business includes its Oceania and Sri Lankan operations and comprises household brands like Anchor and Mainland.

McBride noted that the sale of iconic brands might seem like a cold message to the many people that have an emotional connection to those brands.

"We understand that. Those brands and the associated assets that go with them do hold a lot of value, but to the right owner," he says.

"Fonterra, as a farmer-owned co-operative and the associated cost of capital that come with that model, is not the natural owner of a consumer business."

McBride points out that right now Fonterra estimates the weighted average cost for a dairy farmer is somewhere around 10%.


Read More


He says consumer businesses are inherently more capital intensive and riskier businesses to operate.

"Overlay that with the potentially higher geographic risk in the markets where our consumer businesses operate, and a respectable return on capital for the consumer business should be something north of 15%.

"Our Consumer business had one of its better years in 2024, but despite that, its return on capital was just 6.8%, up from 3.9% in 2023 and 0.2% in 2022.

"We cannot justify investing your money into a business that generates returns lower than your opportunity cost of capital, whilst at the same time exposing you to more risk. We are better off returning that capital to you, reinvesting it into the parts of our business where we have a comparative advantage, or a mixture of both."

Earlier thi month, the co-op announced that it has decided to proceed with the sale - exploring both a trade sale and initial public offering (IPO) options.

At the AGM, shareholder Chris Whiting, Waikato, questioned why the co-op was pursuing an IPO, where the consumer business could be floated on the stock exchange.

Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell replied that their advice was that it is important to keep options open.

"We will thoroughly test the terms and value of both a trade sale and IPO with the market before seeking support from farmer shareholders for a divestment option through a vote.

"A final decision on which divestment pathway to pursue will be based on several factors, including which optin will result in optimal long-term value for the co-op."

Hurrell noted that farmer shareholder support remains critical to proceeding with a divestment.

"We remain committed to presenting an option to you for a vote," he told the AGM.

"Before we do this, we need to thoroughly test the merits and value of both a trade sale and IPO, so that we can be clear on what we're seeking you to approve.

"I recognise there is significant interest in this process, and we will keep you updated as this work progresses. This is a pivotal time for the co-op. While we are confident in our strategic direction, we don't make decisions lightly. Every choice we make is grounded in what's in the best interests of our farmer shareholders."

More like this

Bovaer's fate

OPINION: The fate of methane inhibitor Bovaer in NZ farming is still up in the air.

Synlait sweetens milk supply deal

Canterbury milk processor Synlait is confident of retaining its farmer supplier base following a turnaround in its financial performance.

Featured

Development rewarded at youth camp

Zara Williams' personal and professional growth has seen her presented with the top award at the 2025 World Wide Sires national all dairy breeds youth camp.

State farmer cultivates talent with apprenticeship scheme

To mark International Day of Education on January 24, 2025, state farmer Pāmu (Landcorp) announced the commencement of its Apprenticeship Scheme, designed to equip the next generation of farmers with the skills, knowledge, and experience needed for a thriving career in agriculture.

Insights from within the cow

smaXtec's bolus technology supports early detection of potential diseases, enabling preventive measures to improve herd health and reproductive outcomes.

National

Machinery & Products

Loosening soil without fuss

Distributed in New Zealand by Carrfields, Grange Farm Machinery is based in the Holderness region of East Yorkshire – an…

JCB unveils new models

The first of the UK’s agricultural trade shows was recently held at the NEC Centre in Birmingham.

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Times have changed

OPINION: Back in the 1960s and '70s, and even into the '80s, successive National government Agriculture Ministers and Trade Ministers…

Hallelujah moment

OPINION: The new Public Service Commissioner Sir Brian Roche has just had the hallelujah moment of the 21st century in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter