Thursday, 10 October 2024 12:55

Editorial: Smithfield closure just the start?

Written by  Staff Reporters
The closure of Alliance's Smithfield plant at Timaru will prove yet another blow for the heartland. The closure of Alliance's Smithfield plant at Timaru will prove yet another blow for the heartland.

OPINION: Rural New Zealand has been taking some very big hits of late. The latest of these, the closure of Alliance’s Smithfield plant at Timaru, is yet another blow for the heartland – the engine room of the economy.

Farmers are struggling with the effects of adverse weather, terrible prices for lamb and having to sell their products in an unstable global market.

For the workers at Smithfield it is a bitter blow. They are highly skilled people who have played a huge part in the local and national economy. There are also the other people who have support roles around the processing plant who will now have the unenviable task of finding work and maybe having to leave the district.

While many may see the closure of the 139-year-old Smithfield plant as a surprise, the fact is that this has been a storm coming and the fact that it’s taken so long to happen is itself a surprise. Alliance rightly points to the age of the plant and need for investment to upgrade it. Another major factor is declining stock numbers, so the economics of an upgrade don’t cut the mustard. Unfortunately, Smithfield is the area where the declining stock has had a significant impact, says Alliance.

But there are other things in play as well.

Land use change – for the worse – has seen pine trees planted on good sheep country, with the result that the national ewe flock continues to drop. That is not the fault of Alliance, rather questionable economic policies which encourage the planting thousands of hectares of land in pines. For what good reason, many ask. Carbon farming, they say.

The other factor at play with Smithfield is urban encroachment and there are rumours in Timaru that a developer is interested in the site for retail or other business options.


Read More


There is talk that the coolstores at the site may be kept as they are believed to be in reasonable condition. Little is for certain now.

What is certain is that there could be more closures like Smithfield if stock numbers continue to decline and newer plants with greater capacity and are better designed to better meet the needs of overseas consumers take over from the older plants.

More like this

Editorial: Marlborough's viticulture evolution

OPINION: When I moved to Marlborough two decades ago, I found countless lines of tidy vines, neatly mowed and carefully sprayed, with diligent conventional practices interspersed with the odd organic or cover-cropping outlier, like Te Whare Ra.

'Told you so'

OPINION: Your old mate hears some of the farmers involved in the Meat Industry Excellence (MIE) group ten years ago think the Alliance deal with Irish company Dawn Meats is “an absolute disaster” – and is the kind of outcome they predicted back then if nothing changed.

Featured

HortNZ celebrates 20 Years

More than 150 people turned up at Parliament recently to celebrate the 20th anniversary of Horticulture New Zealand (HortNZ).

National

India FTA negotiations end

A landmark moment for New Zealand. That's how  Prime Minister Christopher Luxon describes the conclusion of negotiations for an India-New…

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Yes, Minister!

OPINION: The release of the Natural Environment Bill and Planning Bill to replace the Resource Management Act is a red-letter day…

Two-legged pests

OPINION: Federated Farmers has launched a new campaign, swapping ‘The Twelve Days of Christmas’ for ‘The Twelve Pests of Christmas’ to…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter