Wednesday, 23 April 2025 10:25

No more pines!

Written by The Hound

font size decrease font size increase font size
Print
Email

Forests planted for carbon credits are permanently locking up NZ’s landscapes, and could land us with more carbon costs, says the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment (PCE).

The new report, ‘Alt-F Reset: Examining the drivers of forestry in New Zealand’, says that radiata pine is really the only economical tree for carbon farming.

However, it could leave the Crown with future carbon liabilities if they’re damaged by pests, disease, fire or extreme weather events.

Even climate scientists are anti-pine, one saying “the PCE, Simon Upton, is uniquely qualified to provide impartial strategic guidance on New Zealand Forests.

We should be grateful for this as climate virtue signaling and perverse carbon incentives threaten to radically change our rural landscapes in a widespread and visually jarring fashion”.

The key takeaway from the PCE’s advice is ‘‘no to carbon forestry!’

More like this

Editorial: New Treeland?

OPINION: Forestry is not all bad and planting pine trees on land that is prone to erosion or in soils which cannot support livestock farming makes sense.

Farmer warns of hidden risks from forestry neighbours

Farmers who find the land next to them is about to be converted into forestry, face potential damage and costly consequences.

OPINION: Your old mate reckons townie Brooke van Velden, the Minister of Workplace (or is it Woke Place) Relations is now showing how underemployed she is as a minister by initiating an investigation into whether young children should be banned from collecting eggs on farms and feeding animals.

Burn the village

OPINION: There's an infamous term coined by a US general during the Vietnam war, specifically in reference to the battle of Ben Tre: "We had to burn the village to save it."

Purist problem

OPINION: The sudden departure of Jim Ward, manager of Molesworth Station for 24 years, highlighted some major dysfunction in the way conservation estate is managed in this country - the biggest problem, as the Hound sees it, being idealogues who harp on about "taonga" and use all means possible to block sensible commercial operations on conservation land.

Featured

Nathan Guy is the new special agricultural trade envoy

Former Agriculture Minister and Otaki farmer Nathan Guy has been appointed New Zealand’s Special Agricultural Trade Envoy (SATE).

Alliance commissions major heat pump system at Mataura, cutting coal use and emissions

Alliance Group has commissioned a new heat pump system at its Mataura processing plant in Southland.

Fonterra slashes forecast milk price, again

Fonterra has slashed another 50c off its milk price forecast as global milk flows shows no sign of easing.

NZ meat industry seeks removal of US 15% lamb tariff

Meat processors are hopeful that the additional 15% tariff on lamb exports to the US will also come off.

Early drought fears ease in Hawke’s Bay, but caution remains

Fears of a serious early drought in Hawke’s Bay have been allayed – for the moment at least.

Consent Rollovers and $13b Savings: What the new RMA bills could mean

There was much theatre in the Beehive before the Government's new Resource Management Act (RMA) reform bills were introduced into Parliament last week.