Thursday, 19 January 2012 11:14

Crafar sale heading to court?

Written by 

There is no quick end in sight to the Crafar Farm sale saga. A group of locals bidding for the farms are signalling they will take court action if the Overseas Investment Office (OIO) approves the sale to a Chinese company.

Crafar Farms are in receivership. The Crafar Farms Purchase Group lodged a $171.5 million bid for the Crafar family farms in September, as a back-up to a rival offer from Shanghai Pengxin being turned down by the OIO.

Group spokesman Alan McDonald says it has retained leading QC Alan Galbraith and law firm Bell Gully, to lead a legal challenge should the OIO recommend approving the Shanghai Pengxin deal.

"The legal approach seems to be the only avenue to bring some transparency to the application information and the process behind the approval," says McDonald. "Without legal action we will never know how the OIO reached their recommendation to approve the sale of the farms.

"The Overseas Investment Act does not permit consent to be granted for the acquisition of farm land by overseas persons with no relevant farming expertise. Shanghai Pengxin is a construction and property development company that has no expertise in dairy farming. The Chinese are passive investors relying on Landcorp to add the farming component."

Bell Gully partner, David Cooper says a letter has been sent to the OIO advising them of the commitment to seek Judicial Review and asking for a copy of the Shanghai Pengxin application for consent or other relevant information.

"We need timely access to the relevant information held by the OIO to protect the opportunity for our clients to exercise their rights to seek judicial review of the recommendation made under the Overseas Investment Act. Our request was sent to the OIO on January 9 and we've heard nothing since," says Cooper.

The Crafar Farms Purchase Group consists of 10 independent buyers, including the Tiroa E and Te Hape B Trusts (represented by Hardie Peni) and Sir Michael Fay, who all have dairy farming interests in the Central North Island. The Group has come together as the receiver insists on selling the farms in one package. Each farmer in the Group has been allocated the properties they have an interest in buying with no farmer seeking more than two farms.

Receivers KordaMentha have given Pengxin a final deadline of January 31 to go unconditional on the 16 North Island farms. Pengxin is waiting on OIO approval to buy the farms.

More like this

Silver Fern plans 50:50 deal with Chinese

Silver Fern Farms' board plans a 50:50 partnership with China's leading meat processor Shanghai Maling, a listed company based in Shanghai, owned 38% by Bright Food Group.

Wine and the Chinese tourist

As Chinese tourists flock to our shores, the New Zealand wine industry could help enhance their visits by catering more specifically to their needs and tastes, Lincoln University research suggests.

Sheds as secure as can be

There is a limit to what farmers can do to improve security on their farms, says Federated Farmers Dairy chairman Andrew Hoggard.

Interim MD for Fonterra farm ventures

A DUTCH DAIRY veteran Henk Bles has been appointed to the newly-created role of managing director international farming ventures for an initial six-month period.

Chinese charm offence needed – exporter

HIGH PROFILE media coverage is needed in China to get the message out that infant formula products are safe, says Chris Claridge from the NZ Infant Formula Exporters Association.

Featured

Creating a buzz on World Bee Day

The message for the 2025 World Bee Day is a call to action for sustainable practices that support bees, improve food security, and protect biosecurity in the face of mounting climate pressures.

NZ supports rules-based system

Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters often describes NZ as a small and isolated nation situated 'just north of the penguins' but says in terms of global affairs, NZ and other small nations should be judged on the quality of their arguments and not the size of their military.

National

Machinery & Products

Iconic TPW Woolpress turns 50!

The company behind the iconic TPW Woolpress, which fundamentally changed the way wool is baled in Australia and New Zealand,…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

R.I.P. Sir Bob

OPINION: When news broke that Sir Bob Jones had died at age 85, the nightly news bulletins all led with…

Can't help itself

OPINION: Greenpeace claims that the appointment of Dr John Roche as the PM's Chief Science Advisor is handing the powers…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter