Friday, 28 February 2014 16:10

Grass and urine claims challenged

Written by 

With regards to the big promo for AberHSG ryegrass (Rural News, February 4), I know it is that time of the year when all kinds of claims are made about the dozens of pasture seed cultivars on offer.

 I tried AberHSG in 2005 shortly after it became available and while the cows find it palatable enough, like most farmers we find it well behind the more modern NZ ryegrasses for winter/spring production and substantially behind a well managed perennial tetraploid for palatability. However, it is the claims made by Dr Alison with regard to AberHSG being environmentally friendly that cannot go unchallenged.

It is true, in theory, that a higher carbohydrate (starch/sugar) forage provides the energy to give better utilisation of high levels of protein in pasture and therefore less wasted in urine. The trouble is, AberHSG has proven to be poor in this area, as shown by research from 2006-08 by Pacheco et al of the Food, Metabolism and Microbiology, Forage improvement, Applied Biotechnologies Group, Agresearch Grasslands and Institute of Veteriniary, Animal and Biomedical Sciences at Massey University .

Their report, “Seasonal and Dietary effects on the concentration of urinary N from grazing dairy cows” reports how three ryegrass cultivars: AberHSG, old tetraploid Italian Moata, and the diploid perennial Impact compared. To summarise, AberHSG gave a urine N average of 6.4g/L in autumn compared to Impact at 5.5g/L and Moata at 4.5g/L. In spring, AberHSG gave a urine N average of 5.1g/L, Impact 4.9g/L, Moata 2.9g/L. The significantly lower N concentration from Moata will be partly due to the 

More like this

Spelling pastures

To build resident populations of subterranean clover in hill country pastures, sheep farmers are encouraged to spell selected areas for four to five weeks over late spring and early summer if possible.

Featured

RSE Scheme Changes Coming - McClay

Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has admitted that a scheme bringing workers from Pacific nations to work on orchards has become too hard to navigate but says changes are coming.

Andy Macfarlane Joins AgriZeroNZ Board

Canterbury farmer Andy Macfarlane has been appointed to the board of AgriZeroNZ, the public-private partnership designed to accelerate the development and deployment of emissions reduction tools for New Zealand farmers.

National

Machinery & Products

 

 

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

True Reflection?

A fair question has been raised about how member-funded organisations should conduct themselves when taking a public position on any…

Civil Circus!

OPINION: It really is getting harder to lampoon government bureaucrats when they do such a good job of it themselves.…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter