Tuesday, 22 October 2019 11:14

Independence necessary — Editorial

Written by  Staff Reporters

OPINION: News that a group of Fonterra farmers want an independent review of the Fonterra shareholders council may well be the beginning of the end of its ‘lapdog’ reputation.

More Fonterra farmers are joining the call for an independent review following the co-op’s many financial debacles (click here to read).

Ever since Fonterra’s inception and the creation of the supposed shareholder ‘watchdog’, the shareholders council has been seen as little more than a toothless body which just rubber-stamps the co-op’s decisions and acts as a glorified training ground for future directors. That impression has been furthered by the fact that the current chair – and his predecessor — were both former chairmen of the shareholders council.

A resolution for Fonterra’s upcoming annual general meeting, to be held at Invercargill on November 7, wants the independent review to be conducted “immediately post” the 2019 annual meeting.

Lumsden dairy farmer Tony Paterson, the mover of the resolution, wants the review to look at how the council can be “a more effective cornerstone shareholder”. It will also consider if the current model is working for farmers and is there a better model.

Patterson believes Fonterra’s performance is below par and that more effective monitoring by the shareholders council could have prevented the co-op’s slide into red.

However, after the motion of resolution was filed with Fonterra, the shareholders council suddenly announced an ‘internal review’. In an email to farmer shareholders on October 1, council chair Duncan Coull said the council’s review will look at its structure and functions under Fonterra’s constitution.

“We have heard the criticisms and frustrations and have been reflecting on them,” he wrote.

Sorry? The shareholders council’s answer is to conduct its own ‘internal review’ of its functions? You have to be kidding.

As Tony Paterson rightly says, a review “should be independent, not one conducted by the council”.

Fonterra shareholders must be given the opportunity to decide whether the council is fit for purpose and farmers should strongly back the resolution for an independent review.

As the oft-quoted saying goes: ‘The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result’.

It is time Fonterra farmers put a stop the shareholder council’s latest burst of insanity.

» Connect with Rural News

More like this

Two re-elected to co-op

Re-elected Fonterra directors Andy Macfarlane and Donna Smit are looking forward to another three years on the board.

» The RNG Weather Report

Featured

No threat to farming from forestry

OPINION: There’s some agitation out there at the moment about farming being under threat from forestry. Much of what’s circulating is based on misinformation so it’s time to lay out the facts.

 

Women’s stories inspire many

Storytelling will help attract, retain and inspire the next generation in dairy farming, says Jules Benton, Dairy Women’s Network chief executive.

Pride is making a big comeback

Pride is returning to the dairy industry, says the new chair of Dairy Women’s Network, Karen Forlong, a Central Plateau farmer.

» Connect with Rural News

» Connect with Rural News

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Job hunting?

A mate of the Hound reckons outgoing special agricultural trade envoy Mike Petersen, who is due to finish his current…

Hot air?

With the Government wanting to implement huge costs on the livestock farming sector by making New Zealand the only country…

» Connect with Rural News