Wednesday, 07 June 2023 09:55

Science behind ETS needs a reassessment

Written by  Jock Allison
Former AgResearch Invermay head Jock Allison says science is never settled. Former AgResearch Invermay head Jock Allison says science is never settled.

OPINION: Government, industry representatives and media always state: “our commentary, policy etc., is science based” and “the science is settled”.

But science is never settled as commonly claimed.

For example, the three estimates of the warming effect of methane are:

The Greenhouse Effect is 75% water vapour, 25% CO2 and trivial effects for methane and nitrous oxide. Methane is 7-8 times more effective re warming than CO2 = 1. The IPCC in its 2021 report states “expressing methane emissions as CO2 equivalent of 28, overstates the effect on global surface temperature by a factor of 3-4”.

This error is corrected by using Global Warming Potential (GWP) of 7-8x more effective than CO2. This is the basis for the GWP* metric, which is being considered by industry.

The cost of ignoring this IPCC conclusion to NZ is about $2 billion/ annum, which is apparently of no interest to bureaucrats and politicians.

Farming leaders (as well as the politicians, bureaucrats and government paid scientists) have no interest in even discussing the research behind the new US conclusions (zero or trivial effect of methane as a GHG). This is in spite of the fact that:

  • This is the actual situation, the most complete "validated model" science,
  • There would be or should be no cost to farmers, or the country for methane emissions,
  • The zero-effect assessed for methane would reduce NZ's total emissions by 30+%; huge cost savings for NZ, and the rest of the world.

The contention that climate policy is “science based” is simply not true.

With about $200 million already spent on R & D with little to show for it, the chances a further $350 million for new research will produce solutions don’t appear too hopeful.

The new metric GWP* is based on very dubious science, but it is not suitable for “on farm” measurement of methane required under HWEN. It could be used for an industry-based approach, which would not require individual on-farm measurement. I would get rid of the immense and expensive bureaucracy and consulting overview required, a huge burden for industry.

Much is made of the split gas approach now enshrined in legislation, which treats methane separately from CO2. With no effect for methane, this is logical.

CO2 is touted as a long-lived gas, much of which is hyped to stay in the atmosphere for centuries to thousands of years. It is not a long-lived gas at all.

The half-life of CO2 is 10 years only. Just how we got to industry commentators saying human CO2 virtually stays in the atmosphere for ever is anyone’s guess.

As John Maynard Keynes said: “If the facts change, I change my mind, what do you do sir”?

Wouldn’t it be a good idea if all the parties could talk to each other for the industry and NZ’s benefit?

Dr Jock Allison. ONZM, FNZIPIM is a former head of AgResearch Invermay.

More like this

ETS myths need busting - Shaw

Green Party co-leader James Shaw says there are myths that have been spread surrounding the issue of the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS).

Future of forests 'concerning'

Could current policy decisions see the demise of the forestry industry? That New Zealand Institute of Forestry (NZIF) thinks so.

Emissions offsetting through forestry at odds with rest of the world

New research has found New Zealand’s policy of allowing fossil fuel emitters to offset all their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by planting trees is at odds with the rest of the world, and it’s having a damaging impact on the agricultural sector and rural communities.


Maui Milk blames supply/demand imbalance

Sheep milk processor Maui Milk says it’s one of many companies being impacted by the imbalance between supply and demand for New Zealand sheep dairy products.

Feds offer support for Maui Milk suppliers

Federated Farmers is arranging support for a small group of dairy sheep farmers in the North Island, who were told this week to stop milking by processor, Maui Milk.


Weather back to normal?

MetService meteorologist James Millward says the country’s weather patterns are now on a much more even footing.

Dealing with SNAs

As Associate Minister for Agriculture and the Environment, Andrew Hoggard has a number of delegations to focus on.

Hoggard's double Act

ACT MP Andrew Hoggard may no longer be hands-on every day at his dairy farm at Kiwitea in the Manawatu,…

Machinery & Products

Kubota tests diesel engines

Kubota last month used the UK LAMMA Show to test the water with its new 200hp, four-cylinder 09-series diesel engines.

Stone collection made easier

Usually a task given to higher horsepower tractors, stone picking looks like its moved down the horsepower charts, to anyone…

A very handy piece

Handypiece is a fully portable shearing handpiece being used by thousands of farmers and ag workers, in diverse roles across…

Killing weed seeds in a single pass

John Deere's X-Series Combine Harvesters can now be complemented by the advanced weed control capability of Redekop’s Seed Control Unit…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Feds power!

OPINION: Your canine crusader reckons no single lobby group has had a bigger turnaround in fortunes than Federated Farmers since…

The DCM award

OPINION: This old mutt suggests the 'don't come Monday' (DCM) award (in other words, resign) must go to the heartless,…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter