Friday, 13 September 2019 08:55

We are not quislings or sellouts

Written by  Andrew Morrison, chair of Beef + Lamb NZ and Jim van der Poel, chair of DairyNZ
Andrew Morrison, chair of Beef + Lamb NZ (left) and Jim van der Poel, chair of DairyNZ. Andrew Morrison, chair of Beef + Lamb NZ (left) and Jim van der Poel, chair of DairyNZ.

OPINION: The suggestion that groups such as DairyNZ and Beef + Lamb NZ are selling the sector out over agricultural emissions is way off the mark and fails to grasp the complexity of the issue.

This article is a response to ‘Sellouts?’ – Rural News, 16 August. Click here to read it.

We accept these are difficult and challenging times for farmers and the sector, but it’s vital the industry works together to achieve the best possible outcome. Farmers have very clearly and repeatedly asked us to work together, and we agree we’re more powerful as a united voice. 

Our bottom line is to ensure that sheep, beef and dairy farmers can continue to have sustainable and profitable farming businesses and that is what we are working towards. If we collectively get this right, then farmers will continue to have sustainable businesses into the future and our industries will continue to be global leaders.

Of course these are difficult issues, opinions will differ and there will be disagreements within the sector, but these differences are at the margins. 

There is in fact broad agreement within the sector on most of the Zero Carbon Bill. We all support the split gas approach -- the net zero target for nitrous oxide and carbon dioxide being reduced to net zero by 2050.  We all agree that the proposed 24-47% reduction range for methane is unacceptable. 

The science on methane is evolving and so there are some nuances in our positions, but we are all fundamentally in the same ballpark and all far away from what the Government is proposing. 

It is unhelpful to suggest that we are collaborators with the enemy. We stand up to the Government when we don’t agree and advocate what we believe is in farmers best interests. On many occasions each of our organisations has publicly questioned the Government’s approach.

We have also spent a lot of time supporting farmers to make practical changes and highlighting to the Government and to New Zealanders the great strides farmers are making in reducing their emissions, improving water quality, soil health and biodiversity. These things matter to New Zealanders and to our customers globally. If we ignore these we risk losing our social licence to operate. 

Throwing stones, slamming our fists and stamping our feet may gain some temporary satisfaction. But in our experience, it’s ineffective in advocacy, risks destroying any chance of policy gains and alienates New Zealanders – the very people we need to convince. 

In fact, what we hear from many farmers is that they want us to engage and find solutions and not just dig in. 

The rest of the country is closely following many of these issues. How we engage publicly is vital. 

That’s why from the outset we have been working constructively with the Government to help create the best possible policy outcomes for farmers. 

BLNZ and DairyNZ have long term strategies that drive what both our organisations do in this space. We’re not just thinking about tomorrow, we’re thinking 20 to 30 years ahead to the next generation of farmers.

We work for farmers’ collective interests to ensure their voice is heard in a range of areas including the environment, trade policy, resource management, biosecurity, animal welfare and food safety. 

We also recognise we must be responsible and prudent with farmers’ money. We’re always looking for efficiencies and driving the dollar further. Importantly, every six years farmers have an opportunity to have their say on BLNZ and DairyNZ and to signal their support for continued investment. 

We’re committed to playing our role in tackling climate change and advocating for all New Zealanders to do their share. We don’t want to be on the wrong side of history.

• Andrew Morrison is chair of Beef + Lamb NZ and Jim van der Poel is chair of DairyNZ.

More like this

Beef+Lamb pushing for changes

Farmer-good organisation Beef+Lamb NZ (BLNZ) says it will continue to advocate for changes to the new fresh water regulations.

Council tasked with making unworkable work

Following a meeting between farmer representatives and environment and ag ministers, Environment Southland will be setting up a local advisory group for freshwater rules.

Farmers try to rectify mistakes

After hearing about problems with the Government’s new freshwater regulations, Tony Cleland organised a meeting between farmer representatives and the Ministers for the Environment and Agriculture.


Longest running ag field days all go

The South Island Agricultural Field Days, held in Kirwee on the outskirts of Christchurch, will celebrate its 70th year in March 2021 with a bigger demonstration area.



Machinery & Products

New tractor fills the gap

Deutz Fahr has introduced the new 8280 TTV, which is aimed at filling the gap between its current 7 and…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Bully boys?

OPINION: This old mutt hears that there is some discontent in the wool sector at the tactics being used by the…


OPINION: Your canine crusader, like many in the rural sector, was deeply distressed to hear the tragic news that a…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter