Thursday, 21 November 2019 10:55

Zero Carbon Bill a missed opportunity!

Written by  Andrew Hoggard, Federated Farmers vice president
Andrew Hoggard. Andrew Hoggard.

OPINION: The Government failed to take on board common sense suggestions for the improvement of the recently passed Zero Carbon Bill (ZCB).

It had a golden opportunity to pass a Bill that was fit for purpose. It could have taken a bipartisan approach to climate change and could have taken farmers along as well.

On November 1, the primary sector put a proposal to the Government which would have achieved the Zero Carbon Bill’s aims and built on the good faith established by the industry-Government climate change commitment -- He Waka Eke Noa.

That was a sad day for common sense. The Government not only walked away from an important part of our commitment to the 2015 Paris Agreement, which requires all its signatories not to forsake food production for climate goals. 

But it also relinquished the opportunity to be true leaders and adopt targets for methane which truly reflect its actual warming impact.

Federated Farmers was also deeply worried by a comment made during the debate on the ZCB by Labour MP and former head of the environment select committee, Deborah Russel, who questioned the usefulness of New Zealand’s ability to produce food.

Russel said: “I’m not sure that we have a responsibility to feed as many people as possible. We certainly want to ensure that we produce food -- it’s one of the things that we export -- but it’s not clear to me that we need to continue producing food at that level.”

The Paris Agreement specifically recognises the “fundamental priority of safeguarding food security” and says policies to address climate change should “not threaten food production”.

A major focus of the United Nations is its sustainable development goals, and whilst climate change is one of those, so too is zero hunger. 

Cutting food production in New Zealand does not prevent people eating, it merely hands production and jobs to international competitors such as the heavily subsidised European Union’s farmers. 

They will just produce the same amount of product, only less efficiently and with higher greenhouse gas emissions.

The unfit-for-purpose biogenic methane reduction targets outlined in the Bill remain unchanged.

The 2050 24-47% reduction target for biogenic methane remains eye-wateringly hard for farmers to achieve and correspondingly dire for our economy to withstand.

With the current tools in the farmer’s toolbox, the only way to meet the top end of the target (47%) is to halve the size of our livestock sector. Even if some of those tools become available, they are not going to universally fit into all farming systems.

The primary sector contributes $28 billion in export earnings to our economy. 

New Zealand farmers are proud to be the most carbon efficient farmers in the world. Forcing them to reduce production is not only going to make New Zealand poorer, but will likely increase global emissions, so we will effectively be shooting ourselves in both feet.

• Andrew Hoggard is Federated Farmers vice president.

More like this

New freshwater farm plans 'practical and affordable'

OPINION: Entering Parliament back in 2023, I wanted to help put the fun back in farming. After six years of Labour, rural New Zealand was tired of the relentless waves of red tape and compliance, draining joy from people who just want to work the land.

Dr Mike Joy says sorry, escapes censure

Academic Dr Mike Joy and his employer, Victoria University of Wellington have apologised for his comments suggesting that dairy industry CEOs should be hanged for contributing towards nitrate poisoning of waterways.

Farmer anger over Joy's social media post

A comment by outspoken academic Dr Mike Joy suggesting that dairy industry leaders should be hanged for nitrate contamination of drinking/groundwater has enraged farmers.

Poultry industry, Govt sign landmark biosecurity deal

The Government has struck a deal with New Zealand's poultry industry, agreeing how they will jointly prepare for and respond to exotic poultry diseases, including any possible outbreak of high pathogenicity avian influenza (HPAI).

Witchunt?

OPINION: Newsroom is running a series of articles looking into the influence of lobbying and has kicked it off with agriculture.

Featured

Fencing excellence celebrated

The Fencing Contractors Association of New Zealand (FCANZ) celebrated the best of the best at the 2025 Fencing Industry Awards, providing the opportunity to honour both rising talent and industry stalwarts.

B+LNZ launches AI assistant for farmers

Beef + Lamb New Zealand has launched an AI-powered digital assistant to help farmers using the B+LNZ Knowledge Hub to create tailored answers and resources for their farming businesses.

National

Machinery & Products

Tech might take time

Agritech Unleashed – a one-day event held recently at Mystery Creek, near Hamilton – focused on technology as an ‘enabler’…

John Deere acquires GUSS Automation

John Deere has announced the full acquisition of GUSS Automation, LLC, a globally recognised leader in supervised high-value crop autonomy,…

Fencing excellence celebrated

The Fencing Contractors Association of New Zealand (FCANZ) celebrated the best of the best at the 2025 Fencing Industry Awards,…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

A step too far

OPINION: For years, the ironically named Dr Mike Joy has used his position at Victoria University to wage an activist-style…

Save us from SAFE

OPINION: A mate of yours truly has had an absolute gutsful of the activist group SAFE.

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter