increase font size
Some NZ manufacturers are unhappy with proposals to change the standards for how infant formula is labelled, marketed and sold to consumers.
A trans-Tasman battle is brewing over a proposal to introduce changes to packaging and labelling regulations for infant formula.
Earlier this year, Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) issued several proposals to change the standards for how infant formula is marketed and sold to consumers.
Several NZ infant formula manufacturers oppose the proposed changes: they come after a review of the standards, which according to FSANZ’s 445-page approval report, were “functioning adequately”, however there was room to clarify some standards and improve alignment with newer international benchmarks.
The proposed new and altered standards include the introduction of new restrictions on the labelling of ingredients within infant formulas.
FSANZ claims in its Decision Regulation Impact Statement that, currently, the labelling and packaging of infant formula are misleading for parents and caregivers.
“For example, consumer research has shown that the marketing of formulas for colic and reflux can suggest to some caregivers that what the infant is eating must be causing the problem and can imply that changing (either from another infant formula or from breastfeeding) to a specialised formula for the condition will solve the problem,” the statement says.
The statement also claims that the similarities between packaging for toddler formula and infant formula – which are often displayed next to each other in supermarkets – have led some parents and caregivers to provide their infants with toddler formula.
It also states that “the majority of caregivers find reading the nutrition information panel on infant formula different”.
However, according to Infant Nutrition Council chief executive, Jonathan Chew, the proposed standards would undermine the ability of parents to make informed choices regarding the food they give their children.
“Several New Zealand manufacturers of infant formula believed this would have significant unintended consequences for their businesses, both domestically and overseas,” Chew told Dairy News.
Thus, late last month, at the trans-Tasman Food Ministers meeting in Adelaide, New Zealand Food Safety Minister Andrew Hoggard voted to reject the standards, something the industry supports.
However, the Australian Ministers – who outnumber Hoggard nine to one – blocked that move, meaning New Zealand will be left to come up with a modified standard.
“It is unfortunate that the Australians believed that in order to protect breastfeeding, you need to make formula as unappealing and complicated to use as possible,” says Chew.
According to Chew, the new standards put Australia out of alignment not only with New Zealand, but also the European Union, the US, and other regions.
“The Infant Nutrition Council believes you can promote breastfeeding without creating confusion and chaos for parents who – for whatever reason – need to use infant formula as the only safe and healthy alternative to breastmilk,” he adds.
Questions emailed to Hoggard’s office remain unanswered when we went to print.
OPINION: While we're on the topic of lumberjacks, Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard has no doubt used a chainsaw hundreds of times, but your old mate reckons he would’ve still been sweating on getting it right when cutting down a pine in front of the cameras, as he did above Queenstown during a recent pre-Budget announcement around extra funding for wilding pine control efforts.
Wilding pines are the wrong tree in the wrong place, and they need to go, says Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard.
OPINION: For thousands of Southland farmers, this week would have tipped them into the non-compliant category when it comes to following regional freshwater plan rules. But the Government has stepped in to give them the clarity they deserve.
Southland farmers staring down a May deadline to submit freshwater farm plans under current regional plan rules have been given an 18-month reprieve by the Government.
Federated Farmers says the Government's announcement of $79 million in funding for wilding pine control marks a major breakthrough.
DairyNZ says Waikato farmers need certainty on Plan Change 1, but they say that certainty must be matched with practical, workable rules and a clear transition that doesn't get ahead of the new resource management system currently under review.
While the Government has moved quickly to make commercial hauliers' lot easier during the current fuel crisis, they appear to be stuck in the creep box when it comes to the agricultural industry.
Waikato farmers have been told that the Government’s new planning system legislation and the region’s Plan Change 1 (PC1) “won’t mesh together very well”.
Farmer owned co-operative Ravensdown has signed a two-year naming rights sponsorship of the Canterbury A&P Show.
OPINION: Confidence in the wool sector is rebounding as prices hit levels not seen in more than 15 years.
More than 300 growers, exporters, researchers, service providers and industry leaders will descend on Queenstown later this month for EXPO 2026, the annual conference for New Zealand’s apple and pear sector.
OPINION: No one messes around with Winston Peters, more so in a general election year.
OPINION: Staying on Federated Farmers, this week's annual general meeting in Auckland is shaping up to be an interesting one.
