Tuesday, 09 December 2014 00:00

Comcom ruling will put formula makers in the clear

Written by 
Nutrition Council chief executive Jan Carey. Nutrition Council chief executive Jan Carey.

AN INFANT Nutrition Council application to the Commerce Commission will show the New Zealand infant formula industry aspires to the highest ethical standards, not only in marketing but also in trade practices, says nutrition council chief executive, Jan Carey.

 The council is asking the Commerce Commission to authorise its members to be able to act in a non-competitive way by restricting marketing of infant formula for children aged under six. Members already do this under their Code of Conduct.

The application is a legal dotting of ‘i’s and crossing of ‘t’s, says Carey.

The council, which represents manufacturers, marketers and  exporters of infant formula in New Zealand and Australia, has in fact had a voluntary code for some so as not to undermine breast feeding.

“It is not enshrined in legislation; it is a self-regulating code which means that in essence it is against our New Zealand laws of anti-competitive behaviour so it is in effect breaking the commerce laws for trade,” Carey explains.

“But the Commerce Commission will authorise anti-competitive behaviour for the greater good and the Ministry of Health suggested that we do this.”

The Code of Conduct has been in place for many years following World Health Organisation recommendations, says Carey. “But there are a lot of new players on the market and we want to make sure that the process is correct.

“The greater good is for the promotion and protection of breast feeding policies and we adhere to that. We make breast milk substitute but we don’t want to be competing with breast milk. But we also choose not to compete with each other in marketing direct to the population and general public.”

Carey says New Zealand and Australia have good marketing practices for infant formula which were developed by the industry here in association with the Ministry of Health.  In Australia it is called the Marketing in Australia of Infant Formula agreement and that is already authorised by the Australian Competition and Consumers Commission. That needed to be formalised in New Zealand also through our Commerce Commission.

“It is part of showing the world that New Zealand has the highest ethical standards for dairy, not only for health but also for trade practices under the Commerce Act. So all government departments recognise the standard of our industry here and especially as it is an exporting industry.

“We had a code of conduct which says our companies will not bring the Infant Nutrition Council into disrepute and that means we expect their conduct in exports markets to be of a high standard in their marketing practices.”

The restrictions the council wants the Commerce Commission to authorise include not advertising infant formula, not distributing gifts or free samples to pregnant mothers or caregivers and not offering inducements to health professionals to promote infant formula. These restrictions give effect to the International Code of Marketing of Breast Milk Substitutes which aims to protect and promote breastfeeding, and to restrict the marketing of breast milk substitutes in ways that would undermine breastfeeding.

The commission may authorise under section 58 of the Commerce Act certain agreements that may otherwise breach the Commerce Act if it is satisfied that the public benefits outweigh the detrimental effects of loss of competition.

The granting of a restrictive trade practice authorisation protects the applicant from court action under the Commerce Act by the commission and private individuals.


More like this

A ticking time bomb

Our dairy industry risks being exposed to a ‘ticking time bomb’ of unethical players unlawfully passing off New Zealand-made and packed milk powder products in China as supplements for babies.

Infant nutrition marketing code launched

The infant formula industry has acted “with great responsibility and integrity” by revising its marketing code of practice, says the Infant Nutrition Council (INC) chief executive Jan Carey.

No future without China

New Zealand's dairy farmer leaders have been told that while global demand for milk is great, there is no future without China.



Stop making decisions for farmers

OPINION: From my observations of general media reporting it seems that in today’s world no one wants to take responsibility for their actions.


Effluent expo canned

The Effluent & Environment Expo, scheduled for early November in Hamilton, has been cancelled.

Fonterra back in the black

Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell says 2019/20 was a good year for the co-op, with profit up, debt down and…

Machinery & Products

Clear cut fodder

CLAAS Harvest Centre product manager, Luke Wheeler, says the end goal should always be the starting point when making purchasing…

Good mower an essential tool

Third-generation dairy farmers Hayden and Tania Edmeades run 500 dairy cows and associated young stock over 190ha near Putararu in…

Mowers get a makeover

Well known throughout New Zealand over the past 18 years, Pottinger has redesigned its rear-mounted Novadisc mowers to incorporate a…

Hardy spotlight

High quality, reliable lighting is essential for anyone involved in agriculture or the great outdoors.

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Eyes have it

OPINION: Painting eyes on the backsides of cows could save their lives, according to new research by Australian scientists.

Walkers versus cows

OPINION: A North Yorkshire teacher has become at least the second member of the public to be trampled to death…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter