Tuesday, 27 November 2018 11:03

Milk price cut ‘will not surprise’

Written by  Pam Tipa
ASB’s Nathan Penny says extra milk from NZ is proving too much for global markets to absorb. ASB’s Nathan Penny says extra milk from NZ is proving too much for global markets to absorb.

With production up 6.5% on last year for the peak of the season, a downward adjustment in Fonterra’s milk price will not be surprising, says BNZ senior economic Doug Steel.

Another “disappointing” Global Dairy Trade Auction last week saw the overall price index fall 3.5% with the whole milk powder price down 1.8% to US$2599/metric tonne. The WMP price has failed to rise in nine consecutive GDT auctions and is at a two-year low.

Fonterra has already revised the forecast twice for the 2018-19 season from an initial $7/kgMS to a range of $6.25 to $6.50/kgMS in October.

The cooperative is required to revise its milk price forecast for Dairy Industry Restructuring Act (DIRA) purposes by December 15, 2018. 

Economists are expecting another revision downwards.

Steel says last week’s result dashed hopes of at least some stability appearing in price.

“Prices have yet to register an increase at an auction since the dairy season started in June. The cumulative fall is now a touch over 20%, seeing prices 12.4% lower than at this time last year.”

Data showed that New Zealand milk production continued its very strong early season run in October. 

“Production was up 6.5% year-on-year in the peak month of the season. This reflects generally helpful grass growing conditions especially compared to recent difficult seasons. This is good for the likes of GDP growth, but comes as a detriment to prices. Combined with a resolute NZ dollar, this makes Fonterra’s milk price forecast range of $6.25 to $6.50/kgMS more difficult to achieve. We would not be surprised to see some downward adjustment over coming weeks.”

ASB has trimmed its 2018-19 forecast by 25 cents to $6/kgMS.

Senior rural economist Nathan Penny says the production season is already one for the record books. October production has set a new record high for any month, building on early strength.

ASB is taking its full season production forecast up a notch to a 5% increase, from 4% previously.

“At this juncture, the NZ production strength is proving too much for global markets to absorb,” Penny says. 

“Fortunately, production is relatively soft in the EU, the US and in Australia. Nonetheless, given NZ’s large share of global dairy exports, particularly of whole milk powder and butter, the mini glut in production is leading prices lower.”


More like this

Forecasts steady as demand holds

Banks are mainly holding firm on their forecasts of $7/kgMS despite last week’s flat Global Dairy Trade result – a small decline of 0.4% in the overall price index.

$8 lamb on the cards

Sheep farmers are in for another year of solid returns, says ASB’s senior rural economist Nathan Penny.

$7 payout still on the cards

Economists are still sticking to a 2019/20 season forecast of around $7/kgMS despite the 3.8% drop in the Global Dairy Trade overall price index last week.

Dairy prices tumble

Global dairy prices have tumbled in the latest Global Dairy Trade (GDT) event.


» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

No tea, we’re vegan

UK vegans are demanding a law change to ban discrimination against plant-based eaters in workplaces.

Fake cows

Even more fibreglass cows may join those seen ‘grazing’ Morrinsville streets for four years.

» Connect with Dairy News