Friday, 10 July 2015 06:00

More fodder beet safer than less

Written by 
Jim Gibbs, Lincoln University. Jim Gibbs, Lincoln University.

DairyNZ advice to limit dairy cows to 8kgDM/head/day of fodder beet is “right in the danger zone” a leading researcher into the crop’s use is warning.

Lincoln University’s Jim Gibbs says limiting intake at that level is highly dangerous because if cows gain access to much more than that, they will eat enough to “crash” the rumen through acidosis.

“It will kill cows. I can’t put it more plainly than that,” he told Dairy News.

A much safer approach is to transition cows to a point where they are at or close to ad-lib intakes of fodder beet. Then, should a breakout or serious misallocation of feed occur for whatever reason, cows won’t eat much more than they’ve been used to.

“At 8kg drymatter a day if they get out they’ll easily eat 12kg but if they’re already eating 12kg/day it’s not a problem,” he explains.

Last week Gibbs presented a paper at the New Zealand Society of Animal Production conference in Dunedin showing once cattle are fully transitioned, ad-lib fodder beet results in a higher rumen pH than ad-lib winter grass.

That finding counters the conventional wisdom that high starch content of beet results in low rumen pH – even acidosis.

A possible explanation is ad-lib feeding encourages more even intake throughout the day and consequently less variation in rumen pH, Gibbs and his co-author Prendergast suggest in the NZSAP paper.

They also found ad-lib beet produced nearly 25% more rumen microbial protein per kgDM eaten, which could explain why mobs of cattle on beet do better than would be expected from their crude protein intake alone, and better than on grass despite its higher crude protein, he says.

The ruminal urea concentration was also higher on beet compared to grass, suggesting cattle on beet recycle more urea through the rumen rather than excreting it.

That has positive environmental implications for stock grazing fodder beet, says Gibbs.

“The amount of nitrogen intake required for the liveweight gains we’re achieving is relatively restricted and the nitrogen excretion is a positive because they are so efficient at using it.”

While the NZSAP paper is based on recent work with steers, Gibbs says there’s no reason why the rumen environment in cows should be any different.

“We have previous data with dry cows, pregnant cows, steers. There’s no difference.”

Given their findings and years of previous work, not to mention widespread on-farm success with high beet intakes, Gibbs says he was left bemused by DairyNZ’s June 2 advisory warning against ad-lib beet feeding and to limit intake to 8kgDM/ha/day plus 4-5kgDM/day of other feed.

In the advisory, DairyNZ senior scientist Gary Waghorn said feeding over 70% fodder beet “could kill some of your cows.”

“Needless to say, my phone’s been running red hot since that went out,” Gibbs said.

DairyNZ’s senior scientist in the feed and farm systems group, Dawn Dalley, defended the 70% recommendation, arguing that where cows are only on beet for 50-60 days over winter, the 30 days required to safely transition cows to an ad-lib regime is too long.

“It comes down to your attention to detail in setting up for winter. We’ve had cows wintered on a 70:30 diet at Ashley Dene [near Lincoln] now for four years with no issues; no breakouts and we’re only using standard electric fencing.”

The trial her colleagues Waghorn and Kay cited was designed to investigate nitrogen metabolism on beet and other feeds and only involved eight cows per treatment. The cows that crashed at 85% beet were transitioned over 20 days and “probably should have been transitioned for longer,” Dalley added, acknowledging there are many experienced fodder beet users succeeding with ad-lib regimes. 

But Gibbs says the need for such long transitions and high supplement rates is not supported by the experimentary data or hundreds of farms experience which shows a 14-day transition is adequate.

More like this

DairyNZ poll

Talking about elections, the DairyNZ board election is shaping up to be a much more exciting affair.

DairyNZ’s new man in Naki

DairyNZ's new Taranaki regional leader, Mark Laurence, plans to help the region’s farmers continue adapting to their fast-changing environment.

Farm lobbies seek PM’s support

Dairy and red meat farmer lobbies want Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern to back their climate change initiative rather than impose a farmer levy.

» The RNG Weather Report


Vaccinations protect people, animals

As we struggle to fathom how we ended up in the throes of a measles outbreak again, we’re reminded of the importance of vaccinations to protect us from life-threatening diseases.


» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Lack of interest

The final list of candidates for Fonterra’s board election is out. Surprisingly only one candidate came through the farmer nominated…

DairyNZ poll

Talking about elections, the DairyNZ board election is shaping up to be a much more exciting affair.


» Connect with Dairy News