Tuesday, 29 August 2017 07:55

O’Connor defends proposed water tax

Written by 
Damien O’Connor. Damien O’Connor.

The farming sector has its head in the sand if it doesn’t realise water is a huge issue waiting to be tackled, says Labour’s primary industries spokesperson Damien O’Connor.

If agricultural organisations like HortNZ or IrrigationNZ “are smart they will show leadership on this issue; if they are dumb, they won’t”, he told Dairy News.

“This simply [requires] a user-pays regime where we need to spend money to clean up waterways, to better monitor what is happening with our water management systems and waterways and for more research.”

O’Connor says user-pays, as a principle, has long been acceptable to the electorate -- including farmers -- but the water issue has been largely ignored for a long time.

“All you have to do is refer to John Luxton’s (former DairyNZ chairman) opinion that for the dairy industry in particular the social licence to operate is quickly evaporating. The industry needs to get ahead of a number of issues.

“A royalty on water would effectively provide funding for storage where it is viable, and for irrigation, better monitoring, research and development and better monitoring of regulations and standards.

“If we don’t do this properly our customers will be rejecting our product. We have to produce the finest, most ethically and sustainably produced products in the world and get a premium for them otherwise our future is not too bright.

“We have traded well on our reputation but there is a lot of pressure coming on and we have to position ourselves at the premium end of the market in everything we produce otherwise the viability of our agricultural system will be at risk.”

A royalty would be applied to all commercial use of water except that coming via reticulated supply. However urban and industrial clean-up of waterways are “just as necessary and need to be proceeded with”.

Urban people would also pay for water clean-ups of sewage and stormwater systems but through a different mechanism, he says.

In rural areas charges wouldn’t be made for stock water but further details “have to be worked through”.

That’s why Labour plans a round-table discussion if elected “because in different parts of New Zealand there are different degrees of reliance on water and different impacts on waterways, as pointed out by Federated Farmers”.

O’Connor says Labour, in Opposition, has not had the resources required to analyse the details sufficiently and properly. They are having to wait pending the resources of Government to establish the finer details of any proposal.

He says if Labour was forced into the detail now it may not be accurate and fair. “We want to be accurate and fair so that what we implement is workable and people can see it is logical. It is important that we be honest.”

He says the National Government was not upfront about increasing GST and that arguably had a greater effect on the farming sector than Labour’s water proposals.

O’Connor says he was a sharemilker when Labour made a hard call in the 1980s to remove farming subsidies that were encouraging uneconomic production and driving up land values.

“Thirty years on some hard calls are again needed. Water is one of the world’s most vital and valuable assets. We have taken it for granted but now realise we have to value and protect it.

“Most of the science, management and restoration of water quality has been paid for by taxpayers and ratepayers but this can’t continue.

“Money is needed for water storage and supply projects, it’s needed for better science and monitoring of waterways and its needed for management of water access rights by regional councils.

“In a relatively efficient economy of user-pays principles it is logical that access to a publicly owned asset should generate a royalty to cover these costs. It happens with oil, it happens with gold and coal and it happens with gravel.”

More like this

Govt out of touch with hort

Horticulture NZ's new chief executive says she's floored by the number of wellbeing issues the sector is currently facing.


OPINION: Your canine crusader reckons the recent immigration reset by the Government, restricting the inflow of 'low-skilled' migrant workers into the country, is not only myopic and ideological but also poorly thought-out policy.

HortNZ backs Biosecurity Amendment Bill

Horticulture New Zealand (HortNZ) says its is thrilled that the Biosecurity (Information for Incoming Passengers) Amendment Bill was drawn from the Private Member's Ballot yesterday.


a2 Milk seals Mataura deal

The a2 Milk Company (a2Mc) has been given the regulatory approval to buy 75% of Mataura Valley Milk, Southland.

Machinery & Products

Giving calves the best

Waikato farmer Ed Grayling milks 430 cows on mostly peat soil that is low on trace elements.

Feed system helping grow top heifers

Feeding livestock can bring with it several challenges including labour shortages, wasted feed, higher prices for smaller quantities, intake monitoring…

Hard hat or hard head

A recently released coroner's report into the death of a South Canterbury farmworker in 2019 raised the question of the…

Made in NZ: Trimax

Made in New Zealand looks at the wealth of design and manufacturing ability we have in New Zealand, creating productive…

Vendro badged tedders

Masterton based Tulloch Farm Machines has introduced a new series of Krone tedders badged Vendro, to replace the existing KW…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Microbe power

OPINION: Microbes fished from the stomachs of cows can gobble up certain kinds of plastic, including the polythylene terephthalate (PET)…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter