Wednesday, 10 February 2016 06:55

Oz competition watchdog takes retailer to task

Written by  Madeleine Brennan
ACCC are alleging the supermarket giant abused its bargaining position when seeking payments from Tier B suppliers. ACCC are alleging the supermarket giant abused its bargaining position when seeking payments from Tier B suppliers.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has begun action against Woolworths.

ACCC are alleging the supermarket giant abused its bargaining position when seeking payments from Tier B suppliers as part of a strategy to reduce its profit shortfall in December 2014.

It is not yet known whether any dairy companies were targeted because, according to the Statement of Claim lodged by the ACCC, Woolworths had no accurate written record of which suppliers were approached, which suppliers agreed to make payments, how much money they contributed or on what basis the suppliers agreed to make the payment.

Fonterra and other Australian dairy companies supply Woolworths.

The ACCC alleges that Woolworths management approved a scheme in which Woolworths sought to obtain payments from a group of 821 'Tier B' suppliers – broadly defined as a group of non-market leaders in their category – to its supermarket business.

"Woolworths' category managers and buyers contacted a large number of the Tier B suppliers and asked for 'Mind the Gap' payments from those suppliers for amounts (ranging) from $4291 to $1.4 million, to "support" Woolworths. Not agreeing to a payment would be seen as not "supporting" Woolworths," the ACCC said in a statement.

"The ACCC alleges that Woolworths did not have a pre-existing contractual entitlement to seek the payments, and either knew it did not have or was indifferent to whether it had a legitimate basis for requesting a 'Mind the Gap' payment from every targeted Tier B supplier."

The allegations claim Woolworths sought about $60.2 million payments from the suppliers, expecting that while many suppliers would refuse to make a payment, some suppliers would agree. Woolworths ultimately captured about $18.1 million from these suppliers, according to the ACCC.

ACCC chairman Rod Sims said the 'Mind the Gap' payments were "unconscionable in all the circumstances".

A common concern raised by suppliers relates to arbitrary claims for payments outside of trading terms by major supermarket retailers.

It is difficult for suppliers to plan and budget for the operation of their businesses if they are subject to such ad hoc requests.

The ACCC is seeking injunctions, including an order requiring the full refund of the amounts paid by suppliers under the 'Mind the Gap' scheme, a pecuniary penalty, a declaration, and costs.

The proceedings follow broader investigations by the ACCC into allegations that supermarket suppliers were being treated inappropriately by the major supermarket chains.

In a statement, Woolworths said it had been fully cooperating with the ACCC during the course of the investigation.

"We believe our conduct was consistent with Australian and international industry practice to engage regularly with suppliers over product and category performance.

"Woolworths believes in working cooperatively with suppliers.

"Woolworths was the first major supermarket to agree to sign the Grocery Code of Conduct and is currently implementing the Code across its business."

Woolworths has until February 15 to submit its defence, with mediation between the parties to start in July.

More like this

Strange bedfellows

OPINION: Two types of grifters have used the sale of Fonterra's consumer brands as a platform to push their own agendas - under the guise of 'caring about the country'.

Featured

India-New Zealand free trade agreement (FTA) dairy outcomes

OPINION: As negotiations advance on the India-New Zealand FTA, it’s important to remember the joint commitment made by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon at the beginning of this process in March: for a balanced, ambitious, comprehensive, and mutually beneficial agreement.

Honesty vital in flood insurance claims, says IFSO

As New Zealand experiences more frequent and severe flooding events, the Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman Scheme (IFSO Scheme) is urging consumers to be honest and accurate when making insurance claims for flood damage.

National

Machinery & Products

New pick-up for Reiter R10 merger

Building on experience gained during 10 years of making mergers/ windrowers, Austrian company Reiter has announced the secondgeneration pick-up on…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Remembering Bolger

OPINION: Is it now time for the country's top agricultural university to start thinking about a name change - something…

Time for action

OPINION: If David Seymour's much-trumpeted Ministry for Regulation wants a serious job they need look no further than reviewing the…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter