Tuesday, 20 August 2019 12:55

Shadbolt eyes return to board

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Nicola Shadbolt believes she has unfinished business. Nicola Shadbolt believes she has unfinished business.

Former Fonterra director Nicola Shadbolt is happy with the review of the director election process.

Fonterra’s first woman director elected to the board, Shadbolt welcomes the decision to give farmers the ultimate say on whether incumbent directors get re-elected: Shadbolt isn’t ruling out another tilt at directorship.

Shadbolt was endorsed by the board for another three-year term on the basis that the board needed to retain some institutional knowledge given that the chair was stepping down. But she was rejected by the independent panel. The rules dictated that a candidate rejected by the panel may not contest the director election that year, so the farmers never had a say. 

The review of director election rules has now removed this provision, ie the independent panel’s power to remove incumbents re-contesting election.

Speaking exclusively to Dairy News, Shadbolt says she was frustrated and angry with the system that sidelined her, but she was powerless under the old rules, so it was time for her to retire gracefully,

Shadbolt was “grumpy” at the co-op’s annual meeting last year as she bowed out of the board. She was required to deliver a valedictory and her speech was gracious.

“I thought ‘farmers don’t deserve a grumpy me; let’s just reflect on the last nine years’.”

Shadbolt says she let her views on the issue known to other board members at a farewell function a few months later.

The old system didn’t give farmers a choice. Basically if there were two board vacancies the board gave farmers two names, saying ‘vote yes or no’. The review was triggered when farmers rejected two of three candidates chosen by the panel -- sitting director Ashley Waugh and Jamie Tuuta. Instead, farmers voted in two candidates – Leonie Guiney and John Nicholls – who had self-nominated for the elections.

Shadbolt is happy that new rules have tidied up the election process. This is despite her having been on the committee that devised the new system. 

During that process the argument was put that a better caliber of directors would come forward through this process. From her observation the new system resulted in the same mix of experienced/inexperienced and effective/ineffective directors as the old system, but with less diversity. The independent panel rejected two female incumbent directors in a row, first Leonie Guiney and then Shadbolt, both diverse thinkers whod challenge the status quo. 

Under the new rules the farmers would have had the decision on whether to accept them back for another term, not the panel. 

Shadbolt isn’t ruling out another tilt at the Fonterra board, saying she feels she has unfinished business. 

She says the board needs experienced directors: noting that apart from chairman John Monaghan, who has served 11 years on the board, there aren’t too many experienced directors.

Guiney is the next most experienced farmer director, serving a total of four years on the board so far.

Nominations close September 27. Fonterra’s board charter states that a director should serve nine years maximum or a final three year term if approved by the board.

More like this

Fonterra's Chinese New Year boost

China's New Year celebrations were almost back on track this year, helping Fonterra record double growth digit growth in its consumer brands sales.


GDT's rough ride in 2020

Incomplete deliveries and logistics disruptions were common issues for the 300 bidders on Global Dairy Trade auctions last year.

Uni farm to shed staff

The Lincoln University Demonstration Dairy Farm (LUDF) is looking to cut staff numbers as it adopts a new “lean” system…

Machinery & Products

Merlo goes greener

Obviously not wishing to get left behind by some of its competitors, Italian manufacturer Merlo is planning to add to…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Oat milk sells

OPINION: Fake milk works for some. Fashionable Swedish alt-milk brand Oatly is seeking a US stock market listing that could…

Labour shortage

If you think labour shortage on New Zealand dairy farms is unique to our country, then think again.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter