Thursday, 25 November 2021 07:55

Why Fonterra needs to change

Written by  Charles Whiting
Waikato-based investor Charles Whiting says he supports Fonterra's proposed capital structure because the status quo isn't working in a declining milk volume environment. Waikato-based investor Charles Whiting says he supports Fonterra's proposed capital structure because the status quo isn't working in a declining milk volume environment.

OPINION: Making a change to any businesses is difficult. Augmenting a capital structure with the diversity of stakeholders and complexity as at Fonterra is a significant challenge.

That said, change is needed and the proposal on foot is sensible and coupled with a refreshed executable strategy.

Fonterra has been plagued in the last decade with what I call an 'ambition-to-ability' mismatch. In short, Fonterra didn't have the necessary skills to take on the world.

Execution was lacking. Poor choices were made around strategy: a lack of quality thinking and diligence characterised investments. Governors failed in not asking the right questions, or knowing what to ask, and effectively let management run roughshod over a national champion. Some farmers rightly left to pursue other opportunities.

It is often forgotten what would happen if Fonterra didn't exist in its co-operative format. It is very simple. Farmers would be squeezed down to accept lower milk prices just above their breakeven. Money wouldn't end up back in local communities and tax and GST takes would immediately impact government. This on-farm economic multiplier effect delivered by an efficient cooperative is critical to New Zealand. Regardless, New Zealand farmers are resilient and continue to deliver quality nutrition to the world.

The core of this need for quality nutrition underpins the new Fonterra strategy. It plays to Fonterra's strengths, taking account of likely New Zealand production declines (mostly from regulatory pressures), the benefits of New Zealand pasture-based milk (both environmental and nutritionally) and Fonterra's world leading research and development capabilities.

Regardless of the new strategy there is one thing that Fonterra needs to deliver - performance. You can have any capital structure, however, if a business doesn't perform it will fail. Behind performance are three clear requirements: a clear articulated strategy, capable people and measured execution against the plan. It is clear to me that elements of this are coming together. Execution must be held to account by the board and, failing that, by shareholders playing a more active role. We cannot afford more thought experiments using shareholders' capital.

Credit needs to be made for work done already. The level of communication and transparency from the board and management has increased ten-fold. The humility of the current management team and board to own up to mistakes of the business - many of which didn't happen on their watch - has been excellent. Coupled with a sensible and achievable strategy they will position Fonterra for a strong future.

Why will I be supporting the proposed capital structure? Put simply, the status quo doesn't work for a declining milk volume environment.

Personally, I would have gone further and brought back the units and also a number of the 'dry shares'. Either way the option remains. Farmers need to think about their shares as a 'right to supply' because if the strategy is delivered, you will be financially better off to supply Fonterra.

This new capital structure, with an executable strategy, give us confidence to invest on farm and let Fonterra do for future generations what it has for past - deliver prosperity and wealth to rural communities and in turn contribute significantly to New Zealand's global understanding. Dairy is enduring: it can deliver perpetual value, unlike extractive resources. Government and regulators cannot afford to forget this. As a smart man once said, "you can't put iron ore on your Weetbix".

Charles Whiting is a Waikato-based former finance executive investing in dairy and other NZ businesses.

More like this

Fonterra reforms greenlit

Fonterra's new capital structure is likely to sail through the parliamentary process without any major changes.


OPINION: Your old mate notes that the highest court in the land, the Supreme Court, recently granted leave for appeal for one Michael John Smith v Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited.


Feds stalwart to step down

Outspoken Federated Farmers leader Chris Lewis is stepping down from the farmer lobby after 17 years of service.

Machinery & Products

India boosts fert subsidy

India plans to double its budgeted 2021-22 fertiliser subsidies to a record of more than 1.55 trillion rupees (US$20.64 billion)…

Kicking lameness into touch

Lameness in dairy cows can have a significant effect on a businesses' bottom line, with vets suggesting that each case…

Single row concept delivers results

While Controlled Traffic Farming (CTF) has become increasingly popular over the last decade, German company Amazone is looking to take…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Fake and cheap

OPINION: First they demanded plant-based 'milk', now they want it priced cheaper than real milk.

Cannon fodder?

OPINION: The recent high-profile Mycoplasma bovis announcement from the Government in Hamilton featured Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Agriculture Minister…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter