Wednesday, 08 December 2021 12:55

Why we need to change

Written by  Greg Gent
Greg Gent Greg Gent

OPINION: Any organisation's capital structure must align with its strategy. That is the mantra and that is something I support.

Additionally, in the case of the co-operative a capital structure cannot be at odds with the co-operative structure and put that structure under such pressure the cooperative is lost. On this basis alone Fonterra's capital structure needs to evolve.

Go back 20 years when Trading Among Farmers (TAF) was put in place. We had very strong milk growth, mostly coming from the non-traditional dairying regions. That necessitated new (costly) stainless stell. The 'value add' part of the then payout was getting diluted by needing to be divided by more and more milksolids.

The logic at the time was "growth funds growth". It was correct and it meant Fonterra received the capital it needed to cater for that milk growth. Fast forward to the current day: the most optimistic forecast would be static milk, with a high likelihood of a falling milk supply, an organisation that has squandered billions of our dollars on multiple poor decisions, and a new group of directors and senior management now in charge. Against that backdrop strategy and by implication capital structure has to evolve.

Like no other time before, Fonterra needs to be competitive in the sourcing of milk. An entry price (share) is an obstacle when the competitors require no capital from farmers. Australia, over the last ten years, provides a good template of what happens when milk supply falls. Stranded assets - with little/no milk going through them - is commercially painful. Co-operatives can fail and Westland Co-op is our most recent example. Should New Zealand's milk supply fall then some current processors will fail.

The board needs to act decisively and fast to get the changes needed to be able to compete in this new world, just as it did 20 years ago.

It's a bitter pill to swallow having a $3 share price on our balance sheets. Apportioning blame typically achieves little, but as I see it, the new guard can't be held to account for that. It's largely a result of actions that happened well before they arrived. The new strategy appears to be way better aligned with our comparative advantage and also is way less capital hungry - a pragmatic solution to our current state by the board, as I see it.

I have thought about what's proposed a lot. It may not be perfect, liquidity and the number of non-milk shares that it will create is a concern. That does however put pressure on Fonterra to perform. The dividend will need to be solid to ensure there is sufficient liquidity (buyers and sellers). Fonterra could also buy shares back in the future if it needed to.

Many of these matters can be worked through over time should there be a problem. What I believe overrides almost all else is a capital structure that is attractive in the market and ensures that Fonterra, as it enters the next phase of its evolution, can compete equally for milk.

We will never all agree on every piece of detail in the proposal.

It's not that detail that will define us but it is that overall change that will ensure we remain competitive and therefore keep our cooperative.

Greg Gent is a Ruawai farmer, agribusiness leader and former Fonterra director.

More like this

All for show?

OPINION: The Hound notes that Fonterra is cashing in on the curent government's largesse with taxpayer money.

JV paying off

Kotahi, founded by Fonterra and Silver Fern Farms, works with exporters and shipping containers to ensure an efficient supply chain.


Ruralco's got your back

Rural trader Ruralco has launched a new campaign, recognising and appreciating the farming sector.

Optimising returns

Last month, in response to some pretty scary price rises, I wrote about the need to control costs. 

Machinery & Products

Amazone's one-pass operation

Ag machinery maker Amazone has paired up its Precea precision air seeder and Combi-Disc 3000 compact disc harrow to deliver…

New grassland products

Grassland specialist Pöttinger has released a new portfolio of products and innovations for the new mowing season.

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Oat juice, not milk

OPINION: New Zealand's best loved brand Whittakers has launched its first 'plant-based' chocolate but it hasn't left a sweet taste…

Heat wave

OPINION: The heat wave that hit Europe last week has forced a rethink among UK dairy farmers who normally graze…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter