Thursday, 26 October 2017 14:55

Fencing works, but more needed

Written by  Peter Burke
Fencing waterways is proven as effective in combatting contamination, says AgResearch’s Rich McDowell. Fencing waterways is proven as effective in combatting contamination, says AgResearch’s Rich McDowell.

Fencing waterways is proven as effective in combating the risk of contamination in waterways.

However, AgResearch professor Rich McDowell says other mitigation strategies need to be looked at because it’s impractical to fence all waterways.

McDowell recently had a paper on a model he developed published in the American Journal of Environmental Quality.

He told Rural News his model is designed to calculate the loads of various contaminants, e.g. nitrogen, sediment and E.coli in rivers and streams, and produce scenarios to help mitigate problems in waterways. An important conclusion is the scientific proof about the value of fencing off waterways.

“Fencing counts,” he says. “We know fencing knocks off 10 - 90% of contaminant transfer from land into waterways.

“It just depends which contaminant you are talking about. For instance, at the upper end you have surface-runoff derived contaminants such as sediment, phosphorous and potentially E.coli; and at the lower end it’s probably nitrogen because it goes lower into the subsurface.”

McDowell says fencing works especially well for E.coli and phosphorous contamination that can result from animal waste or stream destabilisation. But he points out that New Zealand’s topography makes it impossible to fence all streams.

He says the cost of fencing streams high up in a catchment is effectively prohibitive and therein lies the problem.

“We see most contaminants coming from shallow narrow streams in catchments steeper than 15 degrees,” McDowell explains. “Beyond that, there is a component that is natural and a component derived from farming activity. The bit that is natural is between 25 and 75%, depending on the contaminant and local context.”

According to McDowell, the alternative to fencing streams in steeper country is other mitigation strategies -- having an optimal Olsen P concentration, not grazing gullies until later in the season and providing deer with wallow areas away from streams. Such mitigation options are very cost effective.

McDowell notes that in the last ten years an awareness of the issues and good management practices have begun to reverse the degrading of waterways by phosphorus and sediment.

He says fencing in the right situation is obviously a good idea because it’s simple, visual and the concept resonates with the public. But mitigation requires a horses-for-courses approach.

Winter forage crops work in some regions but will not work in others and farmers need an open mind on what is best for their particular circumstances.

McDowell points out that this is not just a dairy problem.

“There are loads of various contaminants coming in from a variety of land uses – dairy, drystock and even the arable and horticultural sectors. They have their own ‘signatures’ in terms of contaminants.

“Equally, they have their own mitigation strategies.”

McDowell says in some seasons very wet or very dry ground causes runoff into streams. His advice to farmers is to mix and match strategies and possibly get a second opinion to ensure action lines up with regional council rules.

More like this

'Living labs' to tackle emissions

Living labs that bring together expertise at locations around New Zealand are among potential solutions identified by researchers to help the country move towards a more climate resilient future.

Meat wellness, well done

Newly published research shows overseas consumers have a strong interest in improving their wellbeing through eating red meat, highlighting opportunities to achieve a premium for products with proven health benefits.

Big opportunities in 'wellness' for red meat

Crown research institute AgResearch has partnered with Meat & Livestock Australia (MLA) to survey attitudes among red meat eaters in Australia and the United States towards physical and mental wellness related to consumption of meat.

Featured

Viability of farming questioned

People are starting to question the viability of sheep and beef farming as profitability in that sector falls to one of its all-time lows, according to Federated Farmers board member and Gisborne sheep and beef farm, Toby Williams.

Zespri's net profit down $60m

Kiwifruit exporter and marketer Zespri has reported a $60 million drop in net profit, mainly driven by reduced licence revenue from lower pricing per hectare than 2022/23.

UAE FTA welcome news

The dairy and red meat sectors have welcomed news that New Zealand will begin formal negotiations for a free trade agreement (FTA) with the United Arab Emirates (UAE).

National

Flock House and its secrets

Plans are in place to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the legendary Flock House opening its doors for the first…

$160 billion cargo shipment deal

New Zealand’s major primary industry exporters have secured shipping capability to export $160 billion worth of products over the next…

Play by the rules

Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay says the Government is always working to ensure that our food exporters are treated…

Machinery & Products

GPS in control

In a move that will make harvesting operations easier, particularly in odd-shaped paddocks, Kuhn has announced that GPS section control…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

True colours

OPINION: The watermelon party (AKA the Greens) try to portray themselves as an upright, self-righteous, caring bunch of woke, bicycle-riding…

Peace at last?

OPINION: Good news for hunters as Forest & Bird have "paused" legal action against the Fiordland Wapiti Foundation and agreed…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter