Saturday, 23 March 2019 11:01

Axe most of TWG’s recommendations

Written by  Andrew Hoggard, vice-president of Federated Farmers of New Zealand
Landcare figures show a methane charge on sheep and beef farmers could cost as much as $120,000 per farm. Landcare figures show a methane charge on sheep and beef farmers could cost as much as $120,000 per farm.

Federated Farmers is calling on the Government to reject most of the raft of new taxes proposed by the Tax Working Group (TWG).

Small business would pay the costs, large business would spend thousands avoiding the costs and tax advisors and valuers would have a field day.

There is possibly an argument for a capital gains tax (CGT) aimed at rental properties if there was sound evidence it would dampen investor speculation and reduce price pressure and first home buyers being out-bid. But even with that, we haven’t given the tougher ‘bright line’ test rules a chance to really kick in.

Labour and their coalition partners must be aghast at the chorus of anger from so many sections of New Zealand society about the TWG’s proposals.

Feds believes they should heed the comments of the group’s chairman, Sir Michael Cullen, who publicly reminded people that he had not promoted a comprehensive capital gains tax during his nine years as Minister of Finance for the Helen Clark-led Labour coalition government.

Sir Michael also said that NZ was so clever we knew a comprehensive capital gains tax was a bad idea or not clever enough to put one in place.

I go for the former conclusion – that on balance a CGT is a bad idea. It’s clear that such a tax would do little extra, above what the Government is already doing, for housing affordability. But it would just add an additional layer of costs for businesses and, given it won’t even apply to the vast bulk of houses, how will it solve housing affordability?

Fairness has been mentioned a lot in this discussion: why should the capital gain on a $2 million small farm in Eketahuna be taxed, but a similar valued house in Ponsonby not. Either everyone is in or no-one is.

The National Party has been quick out of the blocks to start putting numbers on the financial implications of the TWG’s proposal. 

If anything, its estimates on the fallout may be a bit light. For instance, it took a mid-point view on a number of figures.

For example, a 2018 Landcare report calculated that a charge on methane for a sheep and beef farm could be as high as 123% of their net profits – a nationwide cost in the order of $2 billion and a cost per sheep and beef farm of about $120,000.

In our view, the environmental taxes that have been mooted will be even worse than a CGT.

A tax on nitrogen loses will require the use of the Overseer modelling programme, but it has a 20% margin of error. How many people would like IRD to apply a 20% margin of error to their taxes? Overseer is a fantastic tool for what it was developed for, but it wasn’t designed as a tax calculator. 

Also, nitrogen is not the issue in every catchment. Taxing every farmer and grower on nitrogen losses or imposing a tax on nitrogen fertiliser just takes away from primary producers the money they could spend on the mitigations needed for their specific catchment.

• Andrew Hoggard is vice-president of Federated Farmers of New Zealand

» Connect with Rural News

More like this

A lesson in political science

The Zero Carbon Bill has just been passed into law, but not without significant misgivings from across the farming sector.

Milk price hike a surprise and relief

Fonterra's farmgate milk price forecast upgrade was a welcome surprise although indicators were heading that way, says Federated Farmers dairy chair Chris Lewis.

» The RNG Weather Report


What’s your favourite plant?

Forest owners are urging people to vote for tōtara as plant of the year in a poll being conducted by the New Zealand Plant Conservation Network.


Food bowl or toilet bowl?

New Zealand shouldn't become a 'toilet bowl' of trees for other countries' carbon dioxide commitments, explains John Jackson.

» Connect with Rural News

» Connect with Rural News

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Logging spin

OPINION: The Hound notes that the foreign-owned and controlled NZ forestry industry is starting to feel the pressure of the…

EU waste

OPINION: This old mutt was interested to read a recent New York Times expose of the European Union’s agriculture subsidy…

» Connect with Rural News