Thursday, 12 May 2016 07:55

Misplaced advocacy — Editorial

Written by 
The group was protesting about ACC's investment in the Ruataniwha irrigation scheme in Hawkes Bay. The group was protesting about ACC's investment in the Ruataniwha irrigation scheme in Hawkes Bay.

Greenpeace is known for pulling stunts that land it on newspaper front pages and prime time news.

And we think that was the prime motive in its action last week: delivering eight tanks of cow effluent to the front door of ACC's Molesworth St offices in Wellington. Office workers arriving at the building found the main doors blocked and had to use a side door.

Apart from the stench caused by the action, one wonders what else Greenpeace has achieved.

The group was protesting about ACC's investment in the Ruataniwha irrigation scheme in Hawkes Bay; 196 farms have signed up to the $900 million scheme that guarantees water for farming in the region.

The Ruataniwha dam scheme was not put together overnight; it has gone through a lengthy process and has stringent environmental conditions attached to it.

But Greenpeace does not approve; it feels this is throwing away taxpayer money on an environmentally damaging project. Dairy farm effluent ends up in waterways, so schemes such as Ruataniwha, supporting more dairy farms, add to the pollution, it argues.

But, hang on, isn't Greenpeace barking up the wrong tree over Ruataniwha?

Federated Farmers says those using the stored water will be doing so within strict resource consent conditions that have been through rigorous process. And of the 196 farms signed up so far, only one is a new dairy conversion.

Farmers are very clear: they will either remain as they are and use the irrigation as a form of resilience against dry periods, or start new higher value cropping or vegetable growing operations.

The project's dam will hold about 100 million cubic metres of water and allow growers to irrigate some 26,000ha, potentially boosting Hawkes Bay's GDP by $380 million.

The entire region will benefit from improved access to drinking and stock water and recreational facilities. The Tukituki Plan Change six was developed independently of Hawkes Bay Regional Council by a board of Inquiry and put through various tests in the High Court.

Farmers would rather see Greenpeace give support by advocating to Government the opportunities to the TukiTuki region that will accrue from reliable water supply countering the effects of climate change and patchy rainfall.

They know Greenpeace is displaying its anti-irrigation views -- its opposition to a scheme that will give farmers climate resilience.

Stored water gives communities opportunity for good economic and environmental outcomes.

Farmers see the Greenpeace action as a misguided publicity stunt. We agree.

 

More like this

Ruataniwha dam busted?

The future of the controversial Ruataniwha water storage dam in central Hawkes Bay is in limbo, following the recent local body election.

A damn load of emotional effluent

The Ruataniwha water storage scheme saga has gone far beyond soap opera territory: fantasy has long since replaced fact, the noisy quashing any sense.

Ruataniwha setback?

A controversial land swap deal which would have advanced the Ruataniwha dam scheme may now not go ahead.

Reducing harm plan launched

ACC and WorkSafe New Zealand have launched the inaugural 'Reducing Harm in New Zealand Workplaces Action Plan'.

» The RNG Weather Report

Featured

New hort science scholarships 

A scholarship for up to five students each year, studying Massey University’s Bachelor of Horticultural Science degree has been launched by kiwifruit exporter Zezpri.

 

Taking farmers together on climate change

How we take the farming community with us and what trajectory we are on for climate change response is all open for discussion, says Dr Rod Carr, the new chair-designate of the Climate Change Commission.

High alert for stink bugs

Biosecurity Minister Damien O’Connor is warning travelling Kiwis to be vigilant as the high-season for the crop-eating brown marmorated stink bug (BMSB) is under way.

 

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

If it clucks is it vegan?

Is food vegan simply because it doesn’t come from a cow? This question has puzzled one in five Britons.

Swinging out the lifeboats?

The Fonterra shareholders council announced last week that elections will take place in 10 of its 25 wards.

» Connect with Dairy News