Wednesday, 24 April 2019 11:55

Unqualified ideas on climate change

Written by 
John Roche. John Roche.

There is a mish-mash of information available on climate change, some of which originates from people who are not qualified to speak on the subject, says Ministry of Primary Industries’ chief science advisor, John Roche.

Roche says the argument over whether New Zealand has too many cows is a regional issue, not a national issue, which it has been emotively treated as.

This confusion, he says, makes it hard for farmers to get to grips with the issue. Social media he says has both advantages and disadvantages in terms of the climate change debate.

He says NZ has a unique greenhouse gas (GHG) footprint because our economy is primarily agriculturally based, with approximately 50% of our GHG’s emissions coming from agriculture.

“In most of the developed countries agriculture would be closer to 10% of their emissions. Their major GHG’s tend to be from industry or transport, for which there are solutions - be it alternative sources of power or electric vehicles etc. With our agricultural emissions, especially methane from enteric rumen fermentation, we are dealing with 60 million years of evolution,” he says.

Roche says this is a difficult problem because scientists have the near impossible task of trying to fight nature. He says despite all the good work that NZ is doing, it still tends to give itself a bad rap.

“I call it self-flagellation or whipping ourselves. We hold ourselves to the highest possible standard and because we live in a lovely peaceful country free from political and social turmoil. But, we often don’t celebrate our successes and tend to be very critical of ourselves. We are not as bad as we think we are and I think we need to celebrate that and continue to good work to improve further” he says.

More like this

Fossil Fuel Crusade

OPINION: The global crusade against fossil fuel is gaining momentum in some regions.

Green no more?

OPINION: Your old mate has long dismissed the Greens as wooden bicycle enthusiasts with their heads in the clouds, but it looks like the ‘new Greens’ may actually be hard-nosed pragmatists when it comes to following voters.

Our heifers don’t deserve the climate blame

OPINION: Among the many satisfying jobs on the farm is shifting our Angus heifers onto fresh pasture. They love it. Tails up, they gallop around for a minute, then it’s heads down — those long, raspy tongues pulling in mouthfuls of lush green feed.

Featured

DairyNZ: Waikato Farmers Need Certainty on PC1 Rules

DairyNZ says Waikato farmers need certainty on Plan Change 1, but they say that certainty must be matched with practical, workable rules and a clear transition that doesn't get ahead of the new resource management system currently under review.

Ravensdown Named Naming Rights Sponsor of A&P Show

Farmer owned co-operative Ravensdown has signed a two-year naming rights sponsorship of the Canterbury A&P Show.

Editorial: Wool's Back in the Black

OPINION: Confidence in the wool sector is rebounding as prices hit levels not seen in more than 15 years.

Queenstown to Host Sold-Out New Zealand Apple and Pear Conference

More than 300 growers, exporters, researchers, service providers and industry leaders will descend on Queenstown later this month for EXPO 2026, the annual conference for New Zealand’s apple and pear sector.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Taking On Winnie

OPINION: No one messes around with Winston Peters, more so in a general election year.

Full of Surprises

OPINION: Staying on Federated Farmers, this week's annual general meeting in Auckland is shaping up to be an interesting one.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter